KELLIE TRANTER. Unreasonable silence

So what are we left with? The burial of truth. A closed bloc hunkered down in Canberra who conceal information and who fail to condemn the loss of life of innocents at the hands of either our country or our allies, and who are cut off from the consequences of their own cruelty, stupidity and collaboration. Defence personnel who no longer fight for a better future for Australians.  

On 14 March 2017 7.30 aired an important story by Middle East correspondent Sophie McNeill which suggested that the Australian Defence Force is thumbing its nose at international law and legal conventions in relation to its obligations to track and investigate the civilians killed in its airstrikes in Iraq and Syria.

McNeill’s investigation quoted from a response to my January 2017 Freedom of Information request to the Department of Defence which stated that: ‘The Department does not specifically collect authoritative (and therefore accurate) data on enemy and/or civilian casualties in either Iraq or Syria and certainly does not track such statistics….’

In an evasive answer to McNeill on 20 February 2017 the Department of Defence confirmed: ‘United States Central Command provides daily information about the details of coalition air strikes conducted in Iraq and Syria. Australian air strikes are included in these summaries. In addition, the Australian Defence Force (ADF) provides regular public updates on its operations, including in Iraq and Syria, and aims to balance the protection of operational security with its obligation to be transparent and accountable to the Australian public.The Chief of Joint Operations also conducts regular media briefings. Most recently the ADF provided outcomes into the investigation into Coalition-led airstrikes near Dayr az Zawr in Syria. Statistical data about air operations is available on the Defence website, however, the ADF does not provide mission-specific details on individual engagements for operational security reasons.The Australian Defence Force operates in Iraq and Syria under strict Rules of Engagement (RoE) designed to protect our forces, minimise the risk of injury to civilian non-combatants and strictly comply with Australia’s obligations under domestic and international law. The Australian Air Task Group undertakes a detailed and robust sovereign approval process prior to conducting any strikes, which ensures that Australia’s legal obligations are applied. All ADF personnel are required to immediately report suspected instances of civilian casualties. All reports are investigated, as was the case with the Dayr az Zawr airstrikes.

One wonders why, if ADF personnel are required to immediately report suspected instances of civilian casualties with all reports being investigated, such reports didn’t fall within the scope of my Freedom of Information request.

During McNeill’s investigation Airwars – an independent body monitoring and assessing reports of civilian casualties- confirmed through its US military source that the United States cannot compel Australia or any other country to disclose civilian casualties even if the United States thinks that country has potentially caused civilian casualties.

McNeill’s report was both well investigated and self-explanatory but there’s a story in its aftermath.

McNeill’s investigation deserved closer examination and public comment by the political class, particularly in light of recent revelations of the deaths of countless civilians in the Mosul Jadida neighbourhood as a result of coalition airstrikes. Yet no one within the political class was galloping around the political arena making public comments, raising important questions or fighting to preserve fundamental values. An eerie, unethical, unreasonable silence descended. [I do however acknowledge the recent probing by the Greens in relation to the deadly coalition airstrikes in the Mosul Jadida neighbourhood on March 17].

Once the story had aired the historical record had changed. From that point onwards no politician in Canberra could claim that they didn’t know that our Defence force ‘didn’t specifically collect authoritative (and therefore accurate) data on enemy and/or civilian casualties in either Iraq or Syria and certainly does not track such statistics.’ Putting morality to one side, what better propaganda exists, for those with ill intentions, than to misuse this as evidence that a life of an Iraqi or Syrian counts for nothing by its so called liberators.

Apart from some outraged users of Twitter and Facebook the story sank. Having been involved in issuing the Freedom of Information request referred to in McNeill’s investigation and having witnessed the subsequent silence I was left thinking that no one cares unless they suffer things themselves, that our politicians have no concept of what war means for people on the ground – the hunger, the displacement, the loss of loved ones, the collective suffering – and that war is not only indiscriminate it corrupts everyone.

I personally tried to draw the importance of the investigation to the attention of the Prime Minister Malcolm Turnbull, the Foreign Affairs Minister Julie Bishop, the Defence Minister Marise Payne, the Greens, Andrew Wilkie and to the Shadow Minister for the Defence Richard Marles. It was the response from the Chief of Staff of Richard Marles that best captured the frank silence: ‘Mr Marles has no plans to comment publicly at this time.’

A friend based in Canberra contacted me recently offering words of encouragement. He assured me that although the response to my Freedom of Information request came from a low ranking officer it would have been screened and approved at the highest levels – including the Vice-Admiral-within the Department of Defence and, in all likelihood, crossed the Minister’s desk. He agreed with my assessment that the Australian Department of Defence would have known that as shocking as its response would be to the humanitarian eye that it would go nowhere, that politicians would fall into line and that journalists-who have established relationships with the ADF would not ask questions at the risk of losing ‘insider’ status and/or access.

So what are we left with? The burial of truth. A closed bloc hunkered down in Canberra who conceal information and who fail to condemn the loss of life of innocents at the hands of either our country or our allies, and who are cut off from the consequences of their own cruelty, stupidity and collaboration. Defence personnel who no longer fight for a better future for Australians.

The Australian Minister for Foreign Affairs, Julie Bishop, confirmed in a Statement to the Global Coalition on 22 March 2017 that Australia has undertaken over 2000 ‘sorties’ [bombing runs] in Syria and Iraq. Yet the only publicly reported casualties announced by the Turnbull government relate to the death of Syrian soldiers in September 2016.

Julie Bishop did not remain silent about the humanitarian crisis in Aleppo. Malcolm Turnbull was swift to condemn the recent deadly terrorist attack outside London’s Houses of Parliament.   Yet both remain silent about the atrocities unfolding in Mosul, an area where most of Australia’s military actions are concentrated. The concealment continues, and for no good reason.

What must we do to get our government to account, for their actions and their consequences, at least to the extent of the voluntary disclosure of information such as is provided by virtually all other participants? Why do we not stand up to a government that runs roughshod over both its constituents and their democratic ideals?

Kellie Tranter is a lawyer and human rights activist. You can follow her on Twitter on @KellieTranter

 

print
This entry was posted in Defence/Security, Politics and tagged , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

4 Responses to KELLIE TRANTER. Unreasonable silence

  1. richard le sarcophage says:

    Nothing to see here, just the usual Rightwing hypocrisy and contempt for the lives of Moslems. It plays well in certain sections of Wentworth, and the PM looks after his patrons, and the Murdoch machine relentlessly pushes Islamophobic hatred day in day out. As does the ‘Australian’ of the air-waves, the thoroughly Howardised corpse that was once the ABC. This despicable country is being drowned in hatred, to advantage the Right, and, crucially, the Labor Party hasn’t the moral fortitude to oppose it. It will all end, shortly, when the anthropogenic climate destabilisation that the Right still frantically denies, makes Indonesia more or less uninhabitable, and tens of millions will be forced to flee for their lives-and they won’t head north.

  2. Robin Wingrove says:

    Another ‘incident’ completely ignored by our media involving the RAAF was the attack last September upon a Syrian Army base outside of Damascus. Unreported by the West was that one of the three planes involved was Australian, along with one Danish and one US plane. Also not reported was that according to those being attacked it went on for over one and a half hours which leads to the suspicion that multiple runs were made by each plane and that the frantic calls to the US led forces to call it off from that base were ignored. That we are over there is bad enough but not to have the moral spine to admit our involvement in such action is craven to say the least.

  3. michael lacey says:

    There is overwhelming evidence that a number of wars were planned on various countries. Despite all the evidence the war criminals are still free-

    “Most war crimes fall into one of three categories: crimes against peace, crimes against humanity, and traditional war crimes. Crimes against peace include the planning, commencement, and waging of aggressive war, or war in violation of international agreements. Aggressive war is broadly defined to include any hostile military act that disregards the territorial boundaries of another country, disrespects the political independence of another regime, or otherwise interferes with the sovereignty of an internationally recognised state….”

    Something is very evil when nothing is done about, The Unpunished War Crimes of the War Criminals….
    Iraq, Libya, Syria Afghanistan, Yemen and other countries never invaded Western countries, yet the aforementioned nations are now hell on earth.

    “Silence in the face of evil is itself evil: God will not hold us guiltless. Not to speak is to speak. Not to act is to act.” – Dietrich Bonhoeffer

  4. Peter Small says:

    This is just our PM who hasn’t an ounce of patriotism in his whole body, doing the bidding of Goldman Sacks and the “Deep State”. Thank goodness for John Menadue’s blog. The supposed free press in this country is completely compliant with the “Deep State”. Makes one wonder if indeed the CIA already has the News Rooms of all our media including the ABC censored. The rubbish today on ABC News for example, makes one wonder who exactly is deciding what we hear and what we see!

Comments are closed.