ANDREW WILKIE – The bugging of East Timor cabinet rooms (Hansard extract, 28 June 2018)

Australia bugged East Timor’s cabinet rooms during the 2004 bilateral negotiations over the Timor Sea Treaty. The operation was illegal, unscrupulous and remains unresolved. The perpetrator was the Howard government, although the Rudd, Gillard and Abbott governments are co-conspirators after the fact. I can explain today that the scandal has just gotten a whole lot worse, because the Turnbull government has now moved to prosecute the intelligence officer who blew the whistle on the secret operation, along with his legal counsel, Bernard Collaery.

When the ADF went into East Timor in 1999 there was great public sympathy for the people of that troubled country. But what the Australian people didn’t know was that behind the scenes the Howard government was also grabbing East Timor’s oil and gas – as evidenced in March 2002, when Foreign Minister Alexander Downer withdrew Australia from the maritime boundary jurisdiction of the International Court of Justice and the International Tribunal for the Law of the Sea because he didn’t dare let any independent umpire determine where the maritime border should be. The Howard government then had the Australian Secret Intelligence Service install listening devices in East Timor’s ministerial offices to eavesdrop on East Timor’s deliberations and put Australia in a vastly superior negotiating position. In effect, Downer, and by implication Australia, one of the richest countries in the world, forced East Timor, the poorest country in Asia, to sign a treaty which stopped them obtaining their fair share of the oil and gas revenues, and that’s simply unconscionable.

This episode was obviously appalling in itself, but what makes it even worse is that around this time the Howard government released its white paper on terrorism in which Muslim extremist terrorism was mentioned more than 50 times and Indonesia about 100 times. But, for Howard and Downer, national security was an alibi, not a goal as they diverted precious ASIS assets away from Muslim extremism in Indonesia and instead targeted Catholic East Timor in order to grab its oil and gas. Crucially, the ASIS operation occurred at the same time Islamic terrorists bombed the Australian embassy in Jakarta in September 2004.

What makes this matter even more scandalous is that, some months after all of this happened, the Secretary of the Department of Foreign Affairs and Trade, Ashton Calvert, retired and joined the board of directors of Woodside Petroleum, which was the main financial beneficiary of the ASIS operation; and Downer, who had been responsible for ASIS, worked as a lobbyist for Woodside after leaving parliament in 2008. Commendably, the head of ASIS technical operations complained about the operation to the Inspector-General of Intelligence and Security and eventually obtained permission to speak to the ASIS-approved lawyer, Bernard Collaery, a distinguished lawyer and former ACT Attorney-General. Collaery determined, after 2 ½ years research, that the East Timor operation had been ordered in violation of the Intelligence Services Act and took steps to have his client give confidential evidence at the tribunal at The Hague. Importantly, by this stage, the former ASIS officer would have been making a perfectly legal disclosure in confidential proceedings, and that is what the government feared. On 3 December 2013, ASIO raided the former ASIS officer’s home and the office and home of Collaery. They seized documents and data, and cancelled the former ASIS officer’s passport.  The head of ASIS * at that time was David Irvine, who had been the head of ASIS when the bugging took place.

Regrettably, that wasn’t the end of it, and today I can inform the Chamber of a dramatic development:  the Commonwealth Director of Public Prosecutions has filed criminal charges against Collaery and his client. This is obviously an insane development in its own right, but an insane development made all the more curious by Australia’s recent commitment to a new treaty with East Timor. It seems that, with the diplomacy out of the way, it’s time to bury the bodies.

The bottom line is that spying on East Timor was indeed illegal and unscrupulous. Although it was the Howard government’s initiative, the crime has subsequently been covered up by all governments ever since, and now this government wants to turn the former ASIS officer and his lawyer into political prisoners. But that’s what happens in a pre-police state, where, instead of a royal commission, they lock up people who more likely deserve the Order of Australia. Thank you. ENDS.

* This should say ASIO, which David Irvine headed 2009-14.

Andrew Wilkie  (Denison) on Timor-Leste in H of R 28 June, 11.31 am , draft Hansard:




John Laurence Menadue is the publisher of Pearls & Irritations. He has had a distinguished career both in the private sector and in the Public Service.

This entry was posted in Uncategorized. Bookmark the permalink.

For questions regarding our comment system please click here.
(Please note that we are unable to post comments on your behalf.)

7 Responses to ANDREW WILKIE – The bugging of East Timor cabinet rooms (Hansard extract, 28 June 2018)

  1. Why is it that four ABC journalists have been asked to appear before this “in camera” court for reporting these facts 11 years ago when the Newscorp journalist who broke the storey in The Australian has not?
    Is this another method of silencing the ABC?

  2. Avatar tasi timor says:

    Wilkie et al continue to peddle historical E.Timor propaganda. No Timor Sea maritime boundary negotiations have ever been purely commercial. Geography is permanent, defence interests in the air sea gap are always given high consideration. At a time when some ET leaders were threatening to involve Indonesian and PRC interests to leverage a better deal, it was entirely appropriate for Ministers and analysts to want more detailed information, and to task ASIS with finding answers. That a lazy ASIS had to use sigint shows just how badly they did humint. If that’s systemic, it’s a far bigger problem than Witness K. And in a place like E.Timor, where people betray their own family members for a pittance. How utterly lazy and incompetent.

    DFAT and Defence have not been on the same page. Defence has long coveted a foothold in the archipelago whereas DFAT has more defensively sought to secure immediate Australian interests and limit adverse fallout should E.Timor implode and become a failed State. It scarcely makes any sense to give away territory to an non viable State[let] that could implode, with some parts wishing to return to Indonesia. That was the very real prospect in play in 2006, when Gusmao launched a coup financed by Jakarta, greatly strengthening Indonesia’s position. It’s not hard to see competing Defence and DFAT visions for E.Timor behind the K case.

    Fwiw I don’t for a moment believe the public narrative so uncritically peddled in the tame media.

  3. Avatar Lorraine Osborn says:

    I hope the electors of Wilkie’s seat in Tasmania have the good sense to reelect him. Thank goodness there is at least one person in Canberra shining a light on these deeply troubling and sinister goings on.

  4. Avatar Niall McLaren says:

    Sorry, I should have added: “and the third eye fixed on any possible personal advantage.” Mea culpa.

  5. Avatar Niall McLaren says:

    “This is obviously an insane development…”
    Please be assured that, as a matter of psychiatry, the action of the governments from Howard to Turnbull have not been and are not, in any valid sense of the word, insane. At all times and in all ways, their actions have been perfectly sane, rational, calculated, considered, weighed, debated and planned with consummate diligence and care, with one eye fixed on the statute books and the other on the polls. No element of “insanity,” individual or group, has intruded at any point in the entire conduct of this matter. It may be wicked, but it is not insane.

  6. Avatar R. N. England says:

    The fact that the Australian government and its de jure servants, the security services, have become the stooges of corporations like Woodside, shows how the nation-state is evolving in world history. The Australian government has become the stooge, mostly of oil/gas and mining corporations, the US government of arms corporations, and the British government of stockbrokers and accounting corporations. In the final triumph of Western Individualism, all formerly important institutions are drowned in the icy waters of egotistical calculation. With controlling institutions corrupted into impotence, and each corporation desperate to change the rules to suit itself, the inevitable result is conflict, chaos, and hell on earth. This is happening right now on a world scale, as well as internally in the US.

  7. Avatar Scott MacWilliam says:

    Alexander Downer explained on national TV that he was bound to act in the interests of an Australian firm, Woodside, and asked what else should he as an Australian government minister do. Why all the surprise that then and now, the executive of the modern (Australian) state should in this instance again act as a committee for managing the common affairs of the Australian bourgeoisie?

Comments are closed.