John Menadue. Normalising Crime.

I was astounded when I read what Archbishop Antony Fisher told The Australian last week. The report said ‘Australia’s most senior Catholic cleric has proclaimed that families are more likely than priests to abuse children and rejected a church report that linked celibacy to sexual abuse. Archbishop of Sydney Antony Fisher said that celibacy could not be to blame for abuse, which occurred in every church, regardless of whether it was celibate. The thing about child abuse is most of it happens in families. It is an awful thing we hate to even touch on it, but it can’t be about celibacy because you look around society at the moment, it’s in every church, celibacy or not. It’s in many families and their not celibate, generally speaking.’

The Archbishop is falling into a tendency we all have to normalize crime in our own group, church or community by saying that the rate of crime in our own group is no worse than in other groups.

Cardinal Ratzinger who as Pope failed the Church so badly on sexual abuse of children used this argument at a conference in Spain in 2002 ”…the percentage of these (sexual) offences among priests is not higher than in other categories and perhaps it is even lower…less than 1%of priests are guilty of acts of this type. The constant presence of these news items does not correspond to the objectivity of the information or to the statistical objectivity of the facts”.

Professor Patrick Parkinson of the Faculty Law at the University of Sydney   released last year a sobering Paper “Suffer the Teenage Children. Child Sexual Abuse in Church Communities”. Twice he reviewed the Catholic Churches protocol “Towards Healing”. He was a key adviser to the Catholic Church on sexual abuse issues. He is a remarkably well informed commentator. He has seen the problems close at hand and over several years.

As he says in his Paper he terminated his work with the Catholic Church over the failure of the Salesians in Australia to address sexual abuse issues. He then called for a Royal Commission.

In his Paper he acknowledges the patchy data on sexual abuse but the information pointed in one direction. The Catholic Church has a special problem which is outside the “normal”.

He noted that at “a particular (Catholic) seminary in Melbourne 4.75 % of priests ordained between 1940 and 1966 sexually abused children”. Drawing on US data he concluded that “the rate of conviction (of these priests) is much higher than in the general population”.

In comparing the Catholic Church with other churches in Australia he concluded, “When all explanations have been offered the rate of conviction of Catholic personnel does seem to be strikingly out of proportion with the size of this faith community compared with other faith communities”. Go to for the Parkinson paper

It is no help to try to distract attention from the problems that the Catholic Church faces  by saying that the Catholic Church is no different to others. As Parkinson points out ‘the conviction of Catholic personnel does seem to be strikingly out of proportion’

To say nothing about the abuse of trust.

This is not an encouraging start for the new Catholic Archbishop of Sydney



John Laurence Menadue is the publisher of Pearls & Irritations. He has had a distinguished career both in the private sector and in the Public Service.

This entry was posted in Religion and Faith and tagged , , . Bookmark the permalink.

3 Responses to John Menadue. Normalising Crime.

  1. Avatar Lynne Newington says:

    I don’t know why anyone is surprised.
    The SMH* The turbo charged bishop Sept. 29th 2007 is an indication of where he stands. The “three amigos”, have steadily climbed up the ladder, one politically running amok the other two ecclesiastically.
    And the give me a child till he’s seven he refers to is a little outdated considering.

  2. Avatar Brian F Kennedy says:

    The evidence supports Eric Hodges views completely. Which is not to say it is a simple equation but one element?? But the Francis Sullivan report is evidently true. +Anthony Fisher is seeking excuses for avoiding the Truth??

  3. Avatar Graham English says:

    The other day I wrote down the names of some brothers and former brothers that I have known, all from the same order who have been in serious trouble over sexual abuse. There are about twenty of them. Most are known to the law but some aren’t. Or they were but their cases have slipped off the record. I grew up in a country town and as a young man I knew a few people in jail. You know nearly everyone in a small town. But I know far more now who are or were or are about to be in jail, all of them for sex abuse. That other faiths have abusive members, that families abuse children is not the least consolation. We have a problem, an institutional problem And it is about time we tried to fix it. And we could start by telling the truth.

Comments are closed.