Skip to main content

Menu

Letter

In response to The great AUKUS deception: Australia pays to defend America

AUKUS: the stupidity continues

Mike Gilligan’s article raises a number of critical factors in the whole AUKUS submarine clusterf#*k. These issues must be superimposed upon the myriad technical and political issues that corrode the basic integrity of the AUKUS fiasco.

In the strategic scenario of the hot period of the ‘Cold War’, the overarching strategic plan was that of ‘MAD’ – mutually assured destruction: ‘we have such destructive power that if you attack us we will retaliate with such destructive force that life will cease to exist’.

Gilligan says: “The AUKUS submarines would be built here.. to join US naval operations in Asia and the Pacific, for a lifetime tracking China’s underwater fleet to thwart China’s second strike.”

Absolutely true – but Australia has no strategic capability to deflect China’s first strike. Steel boots are of no use when your legs are blown off.

Morrison, Albanese, Marles etc. did/do not have the basic intelligence to recognise that our best defence is to work politically to make targeting Australia a bad decision. Our situation vis-à-vis China as a major supplier of desired resources is such a more effective defence than these ludicrous submarines that it beggars consideration.

— Richard Llewellyn from Colo Vale