The migration maths falls apart when you look at bridging visas
Plans to slash the bridging visa population are central to Coalition and One Nation migration targets, but the backlog is complex and reducing it would deliver far less to net migration than their policies assume.
Both the Coalition’s and One Nation’s immigration policies to reduce net overseas migration (NOM) and the stock of temporary entrants in Australia are heavily reliant on reducing the number of people on bridging visas (BVs). This is an admirable policy objective. The record number of people on BVs is an indication of a visa system in serious trouble.
I have been writing on this for almost a decade, since the problem first took off under the stewardship of Peter Dutton and Mike Pezzullo (see Chart 1).

BVs are generally granted when a temporary entrant applies for a further onshore visa but that application cannot be processed before the original temporary visa expires.

The dramatic fall in the stock of BVs in 2023 was due mainly to mass approval of onshore student and other temporary visa applicants (see Chart 2). That was not a sustainable solution and the stock rebuilt very quickly as onshore student refusal rates went up again to more usual levels.
Reducing the number of people on BVs is not nearly as simple as One Nation, and particularly the Coalition, assume. One Nation assumes it can reduce the number of people on BVs to around 300,000 (i.e. a reduction of well over 100,000), while the Coalition assumes it can reduce the number of people on BVs to around 20,000 (i.e. a reduction of almost 400,000).
Reducing the number of people on BVs would not make the major contribution to reducing NOM or to the stock of temporary entrants that these two parties hope for. Let me explain why.
The BV backlog is comprised mainly of the following:
- students – around 25 per cent
- permanent family (mainly partners and parents) – around 20 per cent
- asylum – around 20 per cent
- permanent skilled – around 10 per cent
- skilled temporary – around 7 per cent
- other temporary (mainly temporary graduates) – around 6 per cent
The government has been trying to reduce the student BV backlog using highly subjective criteria to ramp up refusals. However, this has led to the backlog shifting to the Administrative Review Tribunal (ART) – see Chart 3.

Cutting off appeals to the ART would not be the brilliant solution that some have suggested. Removing merits review just increases the likelihood the Federal Court will step in. Costs of dealing with appeals at the Federal Court are far greater on a per case basis than at the ART.
Measures to limit legally valid onshore student applications and temporary graduate applications, as Labor, the Coalition and possibly One Nation seem to be proposing, would be more effective but would take time.
Processing skilled permanent and skilled temporary applications more quickly would help reduce the BV backlog but would do little to reduce NOM, as approval rates for these visas are very high.
Permanent family applications could only be processed more quickly if there were places available for parents and partners. Under current practice (illegal for partners), such places are not available and hence these applicants will remain in the BV backlog for years to come.
Finally, there are asylum applications in the BV backlog. After the backlog of asylum applications, particularly at the ART, blew out from 2015 (see Chart 4), the Labor government has tried to process asylum applications more quickly. This has led to some decline in the backlog of asylum applications at the primary stage and at the ART. That has reduced the growth in asylum applicants on BVs.

However, the number of unsuccessful asylum seekers in Australia has continued to grow. The Labor government has recently announced it will put more resources into immigration compliance and associated detention capacity after this was massively cut back under Dutton and Pezzullo. That should lead to some increase in removals and voluntary departures.
But it won’t be anywhere near the levels the Coalition and One Nation are promising (i.e. around 80,000). That means the contribution of such departures to the lower NOM promised by the Coalition (i.e. 100,000 in each of its first two years in government) and One Nation (negative NOM in its first three years) will be significantly less.
The reduction in the number of people on BVs promised by the Coalition (i.e. 400,000 by 2031–32) is just pie in the sky. The reduction promised by One Nation is more realistic, but then it is promising a much bigger reduction in NOM.
This is just one example of how ill thought through both Coalition and One Nation immigration policies are.
The views expressed in this article may or may not reflect those of Pearls and Irritations.











