Albo at CHOGM
Critics calling the prime minister’s trip to the Commonwealth summit self-indulgent miss the point. The gathering offers Australia leverage on climate diplomacy, Pacific standing and a looming UN Security Council bid.
Some commentary in Australia has suggested that Prime Minister Anthony Albanese is being self-indulgent by going to the biennial Commonwealth Heads of Government Meeting (CHOGM) in Antigua. There are much more pressing problems at home. Admittedly Antigua, a small island developing state (SIDS) in the eastern Caribbean, is an attractive destination. But it is unfair to characterise Albanese as a Club Med prime minister. There are good reasons for the prime minister to attend. Not only is Australia a senior member of the Commonwealth, but there are substantial political advantages in his attending, some relating to the Commonwealth, others less so.
In terms of its political evolution Australia was a self-governing dominion within the British Empire from 1901. In the interwar period the term ‘British Commonwealth’ became more normal. From 1931 the Statute of Westminster gave Australia the option of formal independence, but Australian consent did not come until 1942 (largely for technical reasons). In 1949 the Commonwealth changed fundamentally when the London Declaration (agreed to by Australian prime minister Ben Chifley among others) allowed republics (in this case India) to remain within the Commonwealth. After 1949 the correct term became the Commonwealth (of Nations), not the British Commonwealth. From 1965 there has been a separate Commonwealth Secretariat headed by a secretary-general (currently Shirley Botchwey, former foreign minister of Ghana).
With decolonisation the Commonwealth has become predominantly an organisation focused on the Global South. It played a significant role in facilitating peaceful independence in Zimbabwe in 1979–1980 and in assisting the transition from apartheid in South Africa, achieved in 1994. Currently the Commonwealth has 56 members, with significant representation in the Caribbean, the Pacific islands, South and Southeast Asia, and Africa, more than a quarter of the world’s states. Among the Global South countries there are significant powers such as India and Nigeria, but most Commonwealth countries are small states (33). Even though they are not part of the Global South, the United Kingdom (UK), Canada, Australia and New Zealand have significant influence within the Commonwealth.
Clearly the Commonwealth is not a major consideration for Australia’s security and economic concerns that focus more on the Asia-Pacific, especially East Asia and the United States (but not exclusively). Nevertheless, the Commonwealth connection provides helpful entrée with various powers that are significant for Australia’s economic and security concerns, such as the UK, New Zealand, Canada and India, not to mention the Pacific island countries.
CHOGM provides an opportunity for Australia to exercise ‘good international citizenship’ by engaging with issues that are major concerns for the Global South, particularly the challenges of development and climate change.
On the latter point Albanese will have an opportunity in Antigua to win support for the forthcoming climate change COP (Conference of the Parties) in Turkey where Australia is chairing. This also enhances Australia’s credibility with the Pacific island countries.
Albanese will also be able to engage one-to-one with his British and Canadian counterparts Andy Burnham and Mark Carney. Given that all three leaders are on the centre left there should be significant rapport. Carney’s vision for middle powers is highly relevant to Australia, although Australia is constrained from supporting Carney too openly because of the ‘albatross’ of AUKUS.
The Antigua meeting will also provide an opportunity for Australia to lobby for support in its bid for membership on the United Nations Security Council in 2029–2030. A vote in the General Assembly is due in June 2028. Solid support from Commonwealth members would go a long way to meet the requirement for two-thirds of UN members present and voting to be in favour.
In the Caribbean and in the British media much attention has been given to the campaign for Britain to make reparations for the historical wrong of slavery (abolished in the British Empire in 1833). One aspect of the campaign has been to focus on King Charles who will be attending CHOGM in his capacity as head of the Commonwealth (essentially patron, and not a hereditary position). While one can expect some discussion of this issue at CHOGM and some reference to it in the final communiqué, it is not within the capacity of Charles as a constitutional monarch to commit the British government. Burnham has shown openness to an apology while opposing reparations.
Albanese is likely to remain diplomatically low key on this issue. The communiqué from the 2024 CHOGM in Samoa referred not just to slavery but to associated historical wrongs such as blackbirding and the treatment of Indigenous people, both of which apply to Australia. Some of the wealth generated from slavery in other parts of the British Empire found its way to Australia.
Whatever the complexities on this and other issues, it is appropriate and worthwhile for Albanese to attend and contribute. In relation to the UK and the ‘old dominions’ Albanese will be senior among the heads of government attending. It is an opportunity for him to show leadership on the international stage.
The views expressed in this article may or may not reflect those of Pearls and Irritations.





