Israel's lessons for Victoria
The Israeli election has some lessons for Australia. Especially for the Victorian election in four weeks’ time.
As in Israel, a majority of voters do not like the incumbent government and are determined to vote it out. All reputable polls have Labor’s vote in Victoria with a 2 in front of it. None has it over 30. The Coalition hovers around 30 and One Nation is in the low 20s.
Victoria has single-member electorates, not proportional as in Israel. Single-member systems tend to hand a higher proportion of seats to the party with the most votes than their percentage of the vote would warrant and the loser gets a lower percentage. For example, last election federal Labor got a third of the primary vote but two-thirds of the seats. Single-member systems usually produce an outright majority government when there are two major parties and only small minor parties and independents.
But with One Nation scoring more than 20 per cent, the dynamic changes dramatically. Victoria’s election this month will be the first to be affected by that dramatic change.
In all likelihood, the two major parties’ primary vote will not yield either of them a majority of seats. One Nation will get at least 15 per cent of the seats and deny both major parties any chance of a majority. And both major parties say they will not govern in coalition with One Nation.
It will put Victoria in much the same state that Israel is in now. In Israel, voters’ determination to oust Benjamin Netanyahu’s government has resulted in a new parliament (Knesset) with neither the Netanyahu bloc nor the opposition bloc with a majority and an Arab bloc with between 15 and 20 per cent of the seats which neither of the major blocs will allow into government or even be willing to accept its support as a minority government.
The stalemate in Israel is that both major blocs are in the position of not being able to govern without the Arab parties (in practical terms), but politically not being able to govern with them.
That could easily happen in Victoria: both the Coalition and Labor are in effect saying to One Nation: “We won’t govern with you even if we cannot govern without you.”
Victorian Liberal leader Jess Wilson has, thus far, formally repudiated a formal coalition or governing alliance with One Nation, stating: “There is no deal. The only way to change the direction of Victoria is with a majority Liberal and National government.”
The same impasse could easily happen federally in 2028. My guess, though, is that in Australia the jingle of the keys to the ministerial wing is much louder than the solemn promise not to deal with One Nation. And that cuts both ways.
At the beginning of a new parliament, there is no sinking ship for rats to desert. To the contrary, with a full term of government in front of them, enough One Nation MPs could be easily enticed into supporting a Coalition government and vice versa.
When a newly laden political ship has to stay afloat, you will always find some rats to work the bilges.
A significant matter in Victoria will be the position of the governor, former Monash University vice-chancellor and distinguished academic Professor Margaret Gardner, who was appointed by the king on the recommendation of former premier Dan Andrews in August 2023, a month before Andrews resigned as premier.
The governor’s constitutional role after an election is to call upon someone to form a government. When no political party has a majority that can be difficult. Israel’s president, Isaac Herzog, is in that very position now.
Convention has it that the governor acts on the advice of the premier and the governor-general acts on the advice of the prime minister. But that convention gets a bit murky if the premier/prime minister no longer commands a majority in the newly elected lower house. It means there is an element of discretion.
There are options: let the existing premier continue in government and wait for a no-confidence motion on the floor of the House; call on the leader of the party with the most seats to form a government and see what happens on the floor of the House; wait until the political parties finish horse-trading to see if the leader of one of them comes up with an agreement among a majority of MPs; or call a fresh election.
In Israel, the president’s decisions are much more likely to command legitimacy and acceptance than the decisions of an Australian governor or governor-general. This is because the Israeli president is elected by a secret ballot of the members of the Knesset, not appointed by the premier or prime minister of the day.
Alas, Australians rejected the indirectly-elected-head-of-state model in 1999.
The federal constitution and most state constitutions are going to be severely tested under the new three-way voting split which now seems set in for a long time and which means neither major party can govern without One Nation yet neither is willing to govern with it.
It will be like the early days of the Australian federation which saw the Protectionists, Free Traders, and Labor split the vote in much the same way as the vote is now split between Labor, the Coalition and One Nation. That saw the prime ministership change hands nine times in 12 years. Surely, the country cannot afford that now.
Also, in these times of conspiracy theories and misinformation, the discretionary uncertainty of the head of state about government-forming would best be codified or at least made more certain. Two jurisdictions offer solutions.
In the ACT, there is no governor. The electoral commission certifies who was elected. The members are sworn in by the Clerk of the House and their first order of business is to elect a Speaker after which the first order of business is to elect a chief minister who forms a government – no governor, no royal prerogative, no discretion, just rules. After that, it would be good to apply the Papua New Guinea rule that no-confidence motions must contain the name of the new chief (or prime) minister or they would be ruled out of order. Again, no role for a governor to choose between a new government or a new election.
I suspect that the coming turbulence of the majority-denying surge in One Nation support will put constitutional arrangements to the test. But Australians and their politicians are only likely to be interested in looking at fixing constitutional uncertainties in the face of turmoil and crisis. Perhaps it would be better for that to happen in just one state, rather than on the national level. Thank you, Victoria.
A similar situation did not happen in South Australia in April’s election even though One Nation polled 23 per cent of the vote. This was because a popular Labor premier meant Labor attracted 37.5 per cent of the primary vote which resulted in Labor winning 72 per cent of the seats. A bit like federal Labor in 2025.
It is different at the federal level now. The government is a bit discombobulated because it has hardly settled in for its second term when thoughts of the next election are upon it. At this stage of the cycle, the voting pattern does not look like changing. Nor does the opinion of a majority of the electorate that they want to see Labor gone.
It does not help, of course, that Prime Minister Anthony Albanese is caught up in a rorts scandal over a $6 million grant to his local golf course. As the mid-terms in the US are showing, voters in the midst of a cost-of-living crisis are quite sensitive to accusations of rorts and misuse of taxpayers’ money for politicians’ favourite projects.
It means Labor is likely to carry primary-vote polling in the 20s into the election. That thought will be troubling to the raft of first-term Labor MPs. As Samuel Johnson said, “Depend upon it, sir, when a man knows he is to be hanged in a fortnight, it concentrates his mind wonderfully.”
In Australia, the thought of being tossed out of one’s seat in just three years, concentrates MPs’ minds on policy and leadership. History shows that an MP’s fear of losing their seat will transcend any loyalty to a leader. As soon as an MP thinks they have a better chance of keeping their seat with a new leader they will jump. Since 2007, there have been as many mid-term leadership changes in the major parties as changes caused by an election.
But time is short. Unlike in Britain, with five-year terms, there is little time left now for Labor to change and renew.
Polls show that Australians generally support a system of fixed four-year terms. It would certainly improve government in Australia. A fixed term would add to business and bureaucratic certainty. The trouble is the constitutional position of the Senate.
Senators have fixed six-year terms. Usually, half the Senate gets elected every three years, every House election. If the House is to have four-year terms, either the whole Senate would be elected every four years, or half the Senate every eight years. Eight-year Senate terms are too long.
The major parties have objected to four-year Senate terms because it would mean 12 senators being elected in each state every four years. An election for 12 senators would mean a quota of just 7.7 per cent of the primary vote for a candidate to be elected. The major parties think that that would result in far too many shrapnel-party candidates being elected.
But looked at another way, with only six senators being elected, a major party can now only ever hope for two. Over two elections that would give them just four out of 12. With 12 elected at once, on the other hand, a major party would have a sporting chance of getting five.
More importantly, if the size of the House were increased and the Senate went to 14 senators per state every four years, the major parties would do better in the long term than the present system of six senators per state every three years.
And the size of the House should be increased. There has been no change since 1984. In that time the population has nearly doubled putting a huge strain on MPs.
Labor is not being helped by the Reserve Bank and interest rates. The Reserve implies that if the government reined in spending it would help fight inflation. And the Coalition has picked up the theme.
The Coalition chirps the tired theme of wasteful bureaucracy and spending, but is reluctant to identify exactly which spending it would cut, knowing the political outcry that would ensue.
Worse, it has hypocritically voted against every savings measure in the Senate. Its blocking of the trimming of the private-health-insurance rebate to richly undeserving older people is hypocrisy writ large.
Of course, the Coalition is still haunted by the first budget of the Abbott government in 2014. The cuts to government spending caused its approval rating to plummet.
Increasing taxes is equally fraught. That leaves the Reserve Bank and interest rates. Which is no answer either.
This week, I am filling in for my friend and colleague Jack Waterford. When Jack was editor of The Canberra Times he had a poster in gothic script on his wall which said: “The floggings will continue until morale improves.”
I could imagine a similar poster on the wall of the office of the governor of the Reserve Bank saying something like: “Interest rate increases will continue until household economic conditions improve.”
The Reserve increased interest rates four times this year and inflation continued unabated. Another rise is a hot favourite for Melbourne Cup day. But we will not be surprised if inflation continues unabated.
What if the link between inflation and interest rates is nowhere near as strong as the Reserve imagines or history suggests? What if modern economies have changed since the day when a small interest-rate rise would lead quickly to contracting demand and slower price rises?
Outstanding housing debt in Australia stands at about $2.6 trillion. If you add 0.25 per cent to the interest on that, it sucks about $6.5 billion out of household disposable income.
At the same time, Australians have about $1.7 trillion in interest-bearing deposits. So an increase in interest rates of 0.25 per cent will add about $4 billion to household disposable income, adding to demand and inflationary pressure.
Then, out of the $6.5 billion added to the household mortgage interest, nearly 40 per cent of it is levied on investment properties and is tax deductible. That is nearly $1 billion handed back as disposable income to investor households. It is also several hundred million subtracted from the government’s bottom line therefore adding to inflationary pressure.
In short, the Reserve inflicts a lot of financial pain on people who are not in a good position to weather it for not much of an outcome. Meanwhile, people who do not have mortgages (a little more than 30 per cent of households) are not affected by interest rate rises and so their demand for goods and services is unaffected and adds no pressure on businesses to reduce prices to attract or keep customers.
Further, business debt to financial institutions is about $1.3 billion. When interest rises on that debt, businesses try to pass as much of it as possible on to the customers in the form of higher prices, thus fuelling inflation.
In short, the Reserve’s war on inflation is being fought with back-firing rifles and flash-in-the-pan pistols. And they wonder why it is not working. They have jacked interest rates up four times and all they can do when the next inflation figures do not move is shake their heads and repeat the exercise.
Also, price increases are not solely dependent on supply and demand. Businesses often jack up prices to whatever extent that they think they can get away with.
The Iran war is a case in point. Everyone imagined that the totality of fuel-price increases could be put down to the extra cost of getting fuel from reserves and sources not dependent on passage through the Strait of Hormuz. Not so. Much of it was pure profiteering. Fossil-fuel companies sensing the public disquiet and expectation that fuel prices would go up, joined the fray.
The Australia Institute has pointed to Ampol’s third-quarter report to the Australian Stock Exchange. Its net profit in the first half of this year was up a huge 376 per cent from $180.2 million to $857.2 million. That was not on the back of extra sales or production efficiencies at its refinery (which, by the way, is subsidised by the government), but straight gouging and capitalising on chaos.
The profit increase “reflects the strength of the integrated supply chain to capture the benefits from prevailing market conditions”, Ampol said. “Escalation of geopolitical tensions in the Middle East in recent weeks and ongoing constraints in supply of fuel products … continue to be net favourable for Ampol’s integrated supply chain”.
That is war profiteering, and the prices these war profiteers charge will not be affected by interest-rate rises.
In a similar vein, higher interest rates provide an opportunity for the big banks to profit from the bigger gap between the rate at which they borrow and the rate at which they lend. That profit ends up in dividends, usually adding to the disposable income of those who can afford to spend it – again putting pressure on inflation.
The better answer to this is to increase taxes on the people who have a high propensity to spend, not to reduce the disposable income or government help for people who are not spending much and not affecting inflation much. Maybe a tax lever should be given to the Reserve Bank, given that politicians seem incapable of using it.
This article first appeared in The Canberra Times and other Australian media on 31 October 2026.
Republished from Crispin Hull
The views expressed in this article may or may not reflect those of Pearls and Irritations.





