BOB CARR. How the Israeli Lobby operates.A repost

The letter was in the bulging file marked ‘Premier’s Invites’. The invitation was to an annual dinner where a peace prize was presented to a person chosen by the Sydney Peace Foundation at Sydney University. This year they had decided to present the award to Hanan Ashrawi. I knew her from CNN and had been impressed by her dignity.

I didn’t want another night at an official function, no matter how worthy. Yet in the end I responded to the bugle summons of duty. I felt I had to accept. My thinking was that the Western world must reward those Palestinian leaders who choose a negotiated settlement with Israel. This would cement Palestinian support for a peaceful solution. And that would make Israel more secure, my key concern.

I had been a long-term supporter of Israel. In 1977, as a young trade union official, I had rented a room in the Trades Hall, bought some cask wine and invited Bob Hawke to come along and launch Labor Friends of Israel. I had remained its token president ever since and was always on hand to greet delegations and troop along to the Independence Day celebrations. As a young MP I stood on the back of a truck outside the Entertainment Centre, which was hosting the Bolshoi Ballet, and addressed a small Jewish rally attacking the Soviets for not allowing its Jews to emigrate. The same again, outside the Soviet Consulate in Woollahra.

In 1983 I had visited Israel with a delegation of NSW Labor people and had found it congenial enough, if not a revelation, admirable for its strong labour institutions. We met no Palestinians and were not driven around the occupied West Bank.

For years after, I had made myself available to meet Israeli delegations and visitors, mostly gloomy and dogmatic diplomats, including Mrs Rabin, whose haughty brows arched in contempt as she shrugged off questions about a two-state solution and the welfare of the Palestinians.

I and my Labor crowd were in the Zionist camp. I remember joking with John Wheeldon, a former Labor senator and a minister in the Whitlam government, about our special closeness to Israel—with its craggy old Labour Party in permanent power, its collectivised agriculture kibbutzniks who were Holocaust survivors. I entertained a notion that in retirement I might sign up as a volunteer to talk about the history of the Holocaust to counter Holocaust denial. It seemed to me self-evident that the Jews were in fact an exceptional people who had made a contribution to civilisation well above their numbers. I didn’t dream that in feeding this self-image I might be encouraging a strand of thinking that, among other things, had Jews enjoying a view of themselves as the ‘Chosen People’ and therefore entitled to uncontestable rights to the land God gave them.

The issue of Israeli settlements slowly wormed its way into my consciousness, but not enough to undermine my instinctual support for the Jewish state. Which brings me back to the invitation to present the peace prize to Hanan Ashrawi. I ticked the box to accept the invitation with an air of, ‘yet another official function to keep me away from home … but it’s good for the Jews. My attendance will reward a Palestinian leader who has signed up for a peaceful path to Palestinian statehood. That’s got to be good for Israel.’ The storm of criticism that then occurred was a shock, and—I will develop this point—an insight.

Soon after my participation was announced, Jewish leaders launched an ‘international petition’ to force me to withdraw from the award. Sam Lipski, a prominent member of the Jewish community in Melbourne, denounced Hanan Ashrawi as a Holocaust denier. There was not a shred of evidence, and he was forced to withdraw and apologise. There were threats of funding being withdrawn from Sydney University. Its chancellor, Justice Kim Santow, barred Ashrawi from even appearing in the Great Hall. Letters of protest were dispatched about the awards going to a Palestinian, switchboards set aflame with indignation.

This campaign had two objectives: to see that no Australian politician attended the presentation of the peace prize and that the peace prize be withdrawn.

An article in The Australian suggested that by accepting this invitation I had damaged the federal Labor leadership of Simon Crean and quoted an anonymous member of his staff to that effect.

Just as federal Labor is lifting its game, the NSW premier does this unconscionable thing that sets us back—this was the tone of the story planted by a member of Crean’s staff but not, I am convinced, by Crean himself. The day it appeared I received a call from a former colleague, Laurie Brereton, now serving in the federal parliament, who told me in strong language that I should not back down. He said, ‘This group [he meant the Israel lobby, especially in Melbourne] is used to bullying to get its way…You get nothing by backing off.’

I had already reached the same view as Brereton. If I had backed down it would have sent a melancholic message to all Australians of Arabic or Palestinian background: namely that, through its political clout, the other side—‘the lobby’, ‘the community’—will always crush you. I had given my word I would present this prize (ironically, because in one tiny way it would make a contribution to Israel being more secure). I would not back down.

I have never received more support on any single issue in my time in public life. I was stopped in the street by strangers who said, ‘Congratulations on not backing down’. It was the only controversy I can recall where this continued a month after publicity ceased.

The award dinner was a sell-out full of people from boardroom Sydney, who, I realised, had an instinctive understanding of what had gone on here: a plain bullying attempt to silence a side in the debate as legitimate as its opposite.

This is an edited extract from ‘Me and ‘the lobby’’, a chapter in Bob Carr’s just-published book Run for Your Life (Melbourne University Publishing, 2018).

Bob Carr is a former Australian foreign minister and longest-serving premier of New South Wales. He is Director of the Australia-China Relations Institute at the University of Technology Sydney.


The Hon. Bob Carr is a former Premier of New South Wales (1995–2005), a former Australian Minister for Foreign Affairs (2012–2013) and the former Director of the Australia–China Relations Institute, the University of Technology Sydney (2014–2019).

This entry was posted in World Affairs. Bookmark the permalink.

For questions regarding our comment system please click here.
(Please note that we are unable to post comments on your behalf.)

5 Responses to BOB CARR. How the Israeli Lobby operates.A repost

  1. Avatar Hal Duell says:

    Thank you, Bob Carr. This is so good to see, so welcome to read.
    Israel has gone from having the world’s sympathy following WWII to now being seen as the Frankenstate it is. Slowly, as the Jew Taboo fades, the truth is appearing, not in the Zionist controlled MSM press which will require a regime change of its own, but in articles such as this one and in the work of Mearsheimer and Walt in The Israel Lobby, the works of Israel Shamir and in The Wandering Who by Gilad Atzmon.
    The power of the Zionist lobby is truly awesome, be it here or in America or throughout Europe. But the tail can only wag the dog for so long.
    On a very personal note, in my now distant backpacking youth I visited Israel for a few months each in back to back northern winters. I went from being an ardent supporter to the realisation that I had to say good-by to Israel to keep from becoming an anti-Semite. The Palestinians were clearly, to use the vocabulary of those years, the soul brothers.

  2. Avatar michael lacey says:

    Israel has declared themselves an apartheid state now!

  3. Avatar James Ingram says:

    No matter which party is in government Australia, virtually alone among Western nations, time and again votes with the United States and Israel to oppose UN resolutions supported overwhelmingly by the majority of UN member states including other close American allies. What is it Bob that has enabled our very small Jewish minority to exercise such power over our foreign policy? I know of no other similarly placed country that consistently acts against its own national interests as we do. If it is the Jewish lobby why such disproportionate power here as compared with elsewhere? Is it also to curry favour with the United States whose Middle Eastern policy is increasingly determined by Israel? I look forward Bob to reading the full chapter.

  4. Avatar Rosemary O'Grady says:

    Good to see.
    Now all we need is for Labor to tell the truth now (before the by-elections); and for the same ethical logic to be applied- and adopted – in other areas of public life: such as the sequelae to the McClellan Royal Commission and related legal outcomes, a clean-up after the expensive muddle of the eligibility/citizenship dramas, an explanation of Bill Shorten’s sustained mis-representations to the Parliament about said citizenship/eligibility issues, and an application of the same logic to the continuing injustices of MIS-representation (very costly to the revenue) of indigenous Australians – created by non-indigenous politicians, bureaucrats including retirees, academics, selected ‘advisors’ and a mongrel lobby derived from almost anywhere except the largely-non-literate but pretty impressively articulate and analytical population of indigenes who are UN -related to whatis created inside what the perps like to call (‘The Beltway’). Poor fella …. Country!!!

  5. Avatar Jim KABLE says:

    Yes, exactly. I think many of us have made the same kind of journey – from unquestioning support of poor little Israel – survivors of the Holocaust – reading all the post-Holocaust survivor memoirs – tales of dreadful suffering and life-long trauma – wondering about the uglier aspects of kibbutzim and the removal of children from parents – and then gradually realising that Israel is in recent decades actually in the control of vested interest undemocratic forces out of Russia, the US – the UK, too – and with supporters here in Australia – to the detriment of Palestinians – their land, farms, homes and peoples stolen/imprisoned [in ways duplicating the Nazi dispossession of its (mostly nominally) Jewish-background German citizens and intelligentsia] such that Zionism has morphed into a NaZionism – plain and simple. That an ugly Zionist pro-Israel lobby exists here in Australia – to bully/bribe/control our political leaders is cause for true concern (bye-bye Michael Danby) as well as the fact that scores of young people here head each year to Israel to serve duty in its Forces – and are then freely able to return here. Using one or other of their national passports. That our politicians still speak up for Netanyahu and gang tells us that these same Australian politicians are being blackmailed or under other kinds of obligation – or know little of the realities of the state they so eagerly praise. I have been wondering about the reporting of the ABC journalist Sean Rubinsztein-Dunlop of late as he sends garbled messages back from the Golan Heights. Nothing fearless in his scripts. What is going on there?

Comments are closed.