Eric Hodgens. On a Wing and a Prayer – A Personal Memoir.

As priests we were sent out on a mission to spread the Gospel and be pastors of the flock. But it was the secular world that formulated mission statements and pastoral care policies. We had the vocation, but it was the secular world that developed vocational training. We were good at the concepts – but slow at the application. The nuances of Scholastic theology weren’t much help once we got out. The seminary had initiated us into the clerical class but we had to learn our task on the fast track of self-help – launched on a wing and a prayer.

Charlie Mayne, our seminary rector, had convinced us that the lay apostolate was central to the future of the Church. Thanks to Gerry Dowling, my predecessor, the lay apostolate was thriving in the parish. This was an early step towards lay leadership in the Church.

Fast track learning involves reflection on the realities of life. I soon learned that this reflection was effective prayer. It produced change and growth. The seminary spiritual practices were habitual routines. Those who stuck to them religiously showed little growth.

The 60s brought the baby boom – and expanding schools. New schools needed new teachers. Enterprising priests like Fr. John F. Kelly led the move to Catholic Teachers Colleges. The laity responded, first assisting, then replacing, the nuns and brothers.

In 1968 three of us were appointed to study at Melbourne University and to be a “priestly presence” there. Fast track learning took another direction. For the first time I really studied scripture. The Word of God had very human origins. Myth was as powerful as Logos. Sociology, including demographics, taught me that you can predict outcomes which otherwise would be mystery or guesswork. Early into the 70s demographic statistics showed me the looming collapse of the priesthood.

Humanae Vitae, in 1969, became a watershed moment. Its impact on the priesthood was both immediate and slow burning. The wounding of papal authority also undermined clericalism. Laity left the Church. Priests left the priesthood. Seminary enrolment virtually stopped – not to recover. Nearly everyone recalibrated their views, firstly on sexual morality, then on the whole gamut of personal morality and Mass attendance.  Confession went into terminal decline. And the laity did this themselves, sidestepping appeals from clergy.

Taking charge of a parish in the early 70s brought new learning. Parishes must be led and managed. My generation had no business, accounting or management training. Back onto the fast track.

The response of parishioners was exhilarating. Post-Vatican II enthusiasm was at its peak. A new generation of more highly educated parishioners moved into pastoral action, and parish administration. Some studied theology and scripture; others became experts at liturgy and music. I learned that my job was to articulate the vision and enable the ministries of others, not to do it all myself. It was like St Paul’s little group in his epistle 1 Corinthians 12. Theirs were genuine ministries despite some clerical objection to the term. Clericalism continued to wane.

The 90s brought a new scenario. The routine pastoral work of the Church was in demand and appreciated by those who looked for it. But affiliation was relentlessly dropping. Gen X and Gen Y largely opted out. Meanwhile paedophilia by clergy was eroding clergy confidence. This became a bigger issue as episcopal cover-up also came into focus. Bigger names became commonplace in the narrative – e.g. Cardinal Law in the USA. Rome first suggested this was a USA problem. More cases came to light. Perhaps it was an English speaking problem. Then Fr. Marcial Maciel, founder of the Legionaries of Christ and renowned money raiser was finally proved to be a drug user, abuser of his students and even his own illegitimate children. John Paul II accepted his gifts, made a public show of favouring him and protected him when the allegations were indisputable. This highlighted a world-wide pattern of crime and criminal cover-up going right to the top. Look at the Karadima case in Chile embroiling Cardinals Errazuriz, one of the pope’s Committee of Eight, and Ezzarti, his successor in Santiago. (See: Clerical pretentions started to look ridiculous as bishops lost their moral leadership.

As priests were dying out so was clericalism. The seminary exemplifies the polarisation. The clerical profession holds no attraction for the coming generation. Don’t blame celibacy; it is the clerical profession that is being rejected. It is 45 years since we had enrolment levels that could sustain the old clerical model. The clerical ethos and quaint devotion of the seminary appeal only to an odd minority. In practice church leadership is increasingly lay.

Clericalism is legally institutionalised by insisting that the pastoral, managerial and sacramental leadership must be in the hands of ordained priests. Already many parishes have non-ordained leaders who call on ordained people for Eucharistic and sacramental ministry. It is time to let the best leaders in their fields lead. Eucharistic and sacramental ministry – important as it is – then becomes one ministry amongst the others. This ministry could then be filled by men of good repute without clericalising them.

A new pope re-articulates the pastoral style of Vatican II. He wants to eliminate clericalism. Meanwhile a thoroughly clerical bureaucracy still jealously guards its privilege. The pope, too, is on a fast learning curve. We end as we began – still flying – but on a wing and a prayer.


This entry was posted in Religion and Faith and tagged , , , . Consider contributing. Bookmark the permalink.

3 Responses to Eric Hodgens. On a Wing and a Prayer – A Personal Memoir.

  1. Edward Fido says:

    I think the real problem for what used to be the conventional Christian Churches of one’s birth or conversion in this country is that most of the people have left the building and are unlikely to return. The experience of the Roman Catholic Church in this country is not dissimilar in many ways to that of the Anglicans, Uniting Church and similar. Authoritarian clericalism and an inability to deal with paedophilia (the Anglican Archdiocese of Brisbane under its former leader Peter Hollingworth would be a prime example here) were common right across the spectrum. Empty theologising, with little relevance to the real Jesus who trod the dusty streets of Roman Palestine and his shining example in life, as well as flaccid spirituality were and are the real killers. Metropolitan Anthony Bloom, one of the more insightful Christian thinkers and doers of recent times, felt the big problem modern Christians had was their failure to realise that Jesus did not plan to set up an institution but to change the world. Jesus was living spirituality. Many clerics and lay people are spiritually dead and co-dependent. As far as paedophilia goes, most Churches should be in sackcloth and ashes. Having been involved, at different times, with both the Anglicans and Catholics, I welcome the elevation of Justin Welby and Francis to their respective positions. The Churches, as far as I can see, are full of decent, but somewhat inward looking people. They do very good social work. They need an inner revolution. Pray God they get it. Otherwise they will become irrelevant. That would be a real tragedy for this country. At the moment it seems only the Evangelicals and Pentecostals who seem to be reaching out successfully to the unchurched in any number.

  2. Jennifer Herrick says:

    thank you Eric for your historical skim through the scourge of clericalism. Interestingly you left out one major set of people who have and continue to suffer at the hands of clerical entitllement. The female parishioners who have been and continue to be sexaully and spiritually exploited by clerical entitlement exacted on them through abuse of power. Fortunately today there a lot less clerical pedestals. But there are still enough, in the hierarchy of Institutes and Dioceses, as you indicated, to perpetuate the myth that male priests and female parishioners are equals. Nothing of course could be or is further from the truth. Imbalance of power stems from clericalism. It persists today in how hierarchy and clerics treat women who have been exploited, and continue to be exploited, treating such women as products of boundary violations rather than victims recipients of a usurping of clerical power. One day let’s pray, this will end.

  3. Graham English says:

    Thanks for this Eric. Let’s hope the pope on his fast learning curve gives us a hopeful and non-clerical archbishop in Sydney. The names being put about so far don’t inspire much confidence.

Comments are closed.