JAMES FERNYHOUGH. Revealed: This is how much ordinary Australians really earn. (The New Daily June 8, 2018)
June 12, 2018
Acasual glance at the news in recent months may have left youthinking the average Australian earns almost $85,000 a year.
If that soundedinsanely high to you, then your instincts were bang on. An ordinary Australian earns way, way less than that.
But it doesnt appear to have stopped Treasurer Scott Morrison using the figure tosell hisincome tax cuts.
A piece of Treasury modelling giventoFairfaxandNews Corptwo weeks ago appeared to claim $84,600 a year was an average income. And that,by a specious line of reasoning, meant the tax cuts would benefit middle Australia the most.
Butofficial government figures show this is highly misleading. According to figures provided to_The New Daily_by Treasury itself, the average wage is just over$62,000 a year.
And the median wage a more useful measure is just over $55,000 a year.
Figures from the Grattan Institute, meanwhile, show the median tax-filers income is just under $45,000 only just over half the supposed average income used by_The Australian_and others to justify the governments proposed income tax cuts.
So where are on earth are they getting this $84,600 figure? Well
The misleading world of wage data
The $84,600 a year is not plucked out of thin air. It actually comes from the Australian Bureau of Statistics full-time adult average weekly total earnings.
According to the ABS, in November last year the average full-time wage, with overtime and penalty rates, was $1628a week. Multiply that by the number of weeks in a year (52) and you get $84,656.
Sounds fair enough, right? Wrong.
First of all, only 68 per cent of workers are full-time workers, according to the ABS. Include the 32 per cent of workers who are part-time, and the average drops dramatically to around $62,000 a year.
Secondly, this average is the_mean_rather than the_median_. This is a crucial difference. The mean takes the total collective income earned, and divides it by the number of earners. But because some people earn way, way more than others, the mean issignificantly skewed towards the upper end.
As independent economist Saul Eslake put it: If Bill Gates walks into a bar full of ordinary Australians, the mean income of the room has suddenly gone up a lot; but the median income hasnt changed at all.
The median is more focused on actual people rather than abstract numbers. It essentially lines up every worker in Australia from lowest income to highest income, finds the person right in the middle, and that persons incomeis the median wage.
According to Treasury, the median wage or salary is $55,063 a year.
_The New Dailys_calculations, using ATO data which you can viewhere, suggested the median income is closer to $50,000. But either way, nobody is seriously arguing that it is anywhere near$84,661.
And if youre wondering why the graphic above puts average full-time wages at $81,843 well, thats because it refers to_ordinary_earnings. The $84,661 includes penalty rates.
When asked by_The New Daily_, Treasury considered ordinary earnings a more accurate measure.
And now to really confuse matters
Wages versus total taxable income
The ABS figures only refer to wages and salaries that is, money earned through an employer.They do not include other forms of income, such as investment earnings, rental income if you own an investment property, and so on.
As you might expect, including all income pushes up the mean. But surprisingly, it actually_reduces_the median.
Grattan Institute economist Danielle Wood told_The New Daily_the best way to get a picture of what ordinary Australians are earning is to look at what she calls the median tax-filer that is, the median of everyone that submits a tax return.
She estimatedthe median tax-filers income in 2017-18 is just $44,527.
I think focusing on the median tax-filer gives people a better picture of who really benefits from policy change, Ms Wood said.
Often the people the government refers to as the middle are actually high income earners.
For example, people earning up to $90,000 can qualify for the full value of the governments low and middle income tax offset [the first part of the governments three-stage tax cut plan] despite being in the highest earning 20 per cent of tax filers, she said.
James Fernyhough is Money Editor of The New Daily.
John Menadue
This post kindly provided to us by one of our many occasional contributors.