JOHN MENADUE- Sacrifice is being politicised. Militarism is becoming the norm.

Nov 17, 2018

Remembrance is morphing into  acceptance of conflict. The culture war about remembrance being waged by conservatives and the military is winning with little opposition.  The never ending stories of Gallipoli, the Western front and Armistice go on and on. We are celebrating war on a scale that no other country does. Government ministers,  Veterans Affairs, the Australian War Memorial and the media  imbedded in the military complex can’t contain themselves. Public occasions are invariably  backgrounded by numerous  flags and  the military, often regardless of the subject at hand.

So that we won’t ask the hard question WHY we fight in so many futile wars we immerse ourselves in HOW we fight. We are deceiving ourselves.

Australia Day should be a civilian celebration of our multicultural success. But even then the military are there on queue. They back the citizenship celebrations in Canberra with a gun salute and march past. The Navy is conspicuous on Sydney Harbour and we have an RAAF fly past. The military drown out all the mixed groups around Australia who  quietly celebrate our real successes, the richness of our  civil society  with its diversity and  social harmony.

The day after Jan. 26 this year we had the government boasting that it has plans for Australia to become one of the top 10 worlds arms suppliers. This is at the same time as we have announced dramatic cuts in our humanitarian aid program that saves lives. We are to export more military equipment to kill and maim.  Our allies like the Saudis and the UAE welcome our support as they inflict terrible suffering on the people of Yemen. Even a  retired Australian general works for the UAE .

When we arrive at our airports  we see our Australian Border Force decked out in  military-style black uniforms. They intentionally look part of the Australian Defence Force instead of Customs and Immigration officers. There is clearly a message being conveyed. We need to act more like the military

The government runs many scare campaigns ,particularly the ‘continuing war’ against ‘illegal’ asylum seekers and terrorists. The language is clear, we were at war with asylum seekers in their rickety boats. Scott Morrison describes Operation Sovereign Borders run by the Navy as a ‘military-led border security operation’. He adds that the battle against people-smugglers ‘is being fought using the full arsenal of measures’. Peter Dutton tells us that a military look alike called Border Force is more important than ever.

Many of us had hoped that at last we were putting to an end the appointment of the Australian military as vice-regal representatives in Australia. But we are back-tracking on that with General Cosgrove our Governor General and General Hurley our Governor in NSW. The military is the norm.

Our aid programs have been progressively militarised. AIDWATCH has reported that our ‘military forces manipulate humanitarian aid in order to achieve tactical and political objectives. While the military can play an important role in the immediate aftermath of a humanitarian crisis, particularly through the provision of transport and creating a secure environment, researchers have found that militarised aid is not effective and can cause harm to local communities and aid workers’. It added ‘All Australian government activities in Afghanistan that are related to Operation Slipper – whether delivered by the ADF, AFP or Ausaid – are not aid.’ At a Senate Inquiry into Australia’s aid program to Afghanistan in December 2012 it revealed almost $200 million in military spending being reported as “aid”. The acknowledgement raised serious concerns about the close relationship between aid and Australian military and police forces in Afghanistan.’

The militarisation of Australia and our conditioning has been most evident in the extravagant celebration of the Centenary of the Gallipoli invasion and WWI. The Australian War Memorial has orchestrated a well-funded campaign across the country, including schools, to depict WWI as the starting point of our history, our coming of age. Our media love it. The AWM celebrates war by accepting generous funding from arms suppliers, the ‘agents of death’ as Pope Francis calls them. As Douglas Newton put it in this blog, it is grotesque that the AWM accepts money and sponsorship from arms suppliers. The agents of death are well and truly within the citadel. They even fund the Invictus Games,the same people that produce the weapons to maim and kill. Don’t we care?

And then the government agrees, with the complicity of the ALP to fund another $500 m for the  continuing ego trip of the Director of the AWM. When will we get the AWM back on the rails? When will it include memorials to the tens of thousands of indigenous people who were killed in the Frontier Wars? When will it  acknowledge that the Anzac ‘legend’ did not begin at Gallipoli but when Australians went to New Zealand to fight in the Maori Wars 1845-1872.

We are encouraged to celebrate the disastrous Gallipoli invasion and forget our great civilian and peace time achievements in the decades just before 1900 and in the subsequent decade. There were remarkable civilian achievements; federation, the national parliament, a living wage, rights for women and an Australian ballot. We were world leaders in these and other civilian achievements but we are encouraged to forget them so we can focus on our military history and valour. That suited conservatives. And it still does.

WW1 divided Australia as never before, between Irish and English, Catholics and Protestants. It was hardly nation building!

So much of this glorification of war serves the purpose of avoiding the hard question of WHY we fight in so many futile foreign wars that are of no concern of ours. Instead we absorb ourselves in the issue of HOW our heroes fought. We fought in WWI as an Australian IMPERIAL Force so that at some future date the Empire would save White Australia from the hordes in Asia. And the Empire failed us. It is nonsense to say we fought in WWI for democracy and oar way of life. We fought for Britain’s economic interest.

Our foreign policy has become subjected to our military dependence on the US. . We are at the beck and call of the US military, often regardless of our own interests.  With interoperability of equipment and personnel we are locked into the US war machine. We are dragooned time and time again into US disasters– Vietnam, Iraq, and Afghanistan .

Malcolm Fraser has warned us that the US is a ‘dangerous ally’. The US has many attractive features but war seems to be in its DNA. Since its independence in 1776, the US has been at war 93% of that time. It has never had a decade without war. It has launched 201 out of 248 armed conflicts since the end of WWII and maintains over 700 military bases around the world in more than 100 countries. Former President Eisenhower warned Americans about the industrial and military complex in the US. The warning should be for us as well as for the Americans about the militarisation of civilian institutions and values. Our foreign policy has been eclipsed by our mistaken military adventures and dependence on the US. Our Department of Foreign and Trade is sidelined by our military and intelligence complex.

And now our unsupervised intelligence agencies are promoting a China panic  to prepare us for the coming cold war with China, urged on by the US Vice President

There is great danger that the militarisation of Australian history and our ready acceptance of the military as the accepted norm will lead us to more and more tragedy. We used to believe that committing our country to war was the most serious thing that any government could ever do. That is no more. We go to war without even the Australian parliament being consulted.

Henry Reynolds in this blog ‘Militarism marches on’, warned us ‘The threshold Australian governments need to cross in order to send forces overseas is perilously low. Because there has never been an assessment of why Australia has been so often involved in war, young people must get the impression that war is a natural and inescapable part of national life. It is what we do and we are good at it. We ‘punch above our weight’. War is treated as though it provides the venue and the occasion for Australian heroism and martial virtuosity. While there is much talk of dying, or more commonly of sacrifice, there is little mention of killing and never any assessment of the carnage visited on distant countries in our name.’

Blink and we miss another military festival in Australia. Are there so few civic achievements to be proud of?

Anzakery has been with us since Charles Bean and Keith Murdoch persuaded us that we should not ask WHY we are involved in wars but how brave our soldiers were. And they were brave. But it draws us away from the basic question WHY we fight so many futile wars from Gallipoli to Afghanistan. Will the next one be Taiwan?

Militarism is becoming more and more pervasive. We are sleep-walking in dangerous territory..

War and militarism have become the norm. Sacrifice has become politicised.

Share and Enjoy !

Subscribe to John Menadue's Newsletter
Subscribe to John Menadue's Newsletter


How often?

Thank you for subscribing!

Subscribe to John Menadue's Newsletter
Subscribe to John Menadue's Newsletter


How often?

Thank you for subscribing!