John Menadue. The price we are paying for the Greens.

The recent successes of the Greens in state elections in Victoria and NSW show us how populist nonsense can succeed at least in the short term. It has also shown the failure of the ALP to counter the threat of the Greens.

There are two major issues on which the policies of the Greens have brought disastrous results for Australia. When it really mattered on climate change and asylum seekers, they sided with Tony Abbott.

The Greens literally shed tears over the plight of asylum seekers. But they must bear a heavy responsibility for what we now see on Manus and Nauru.

In the Senate the Greens sided with Tony Abbott against the arrangement with Malaysia, which, whilst not ideal, would have been a useful first step in curbing boat arrivals. That arrangement with Malaysia was negotiated with the understanding and broad support of UNHCR. Not only did the Greens side with Tony Abbott opposing amendments to the Migration Act to allow the arrangement with Malaysia to proceed, they embarked on an unscrupulous bashing campaign of Malaysia.

With the collapse of the Malaysian arrangement boat arrivals in Australia increased dramatically. The result was Manus and Nauru. The Greens cannot be absolved for their populism and the consequences we now see on Manus and Nauru.

The Greens must also accept major responsibility for the collapse in public support for effective action on climate change. In collaboration with the Coalition in the Senate they opposed the Carbon Pollution Reduction Scheme of the first Rudd Government. If the Greens had supported the Rudd Government’s CPRS in the Senate, the issue of climate change would not have been fully ‘done and dusted’ but we would be in a far better position on climate change than we are today. As a result of the Greens joining with Tony Abbott in the Senate we have no Emissions Trading Scheme, no carbon tax and a fig leaf of a policy called ‘Direct Action’.

The Greens have inflicted disastrous damage to Australia on both climate change and asylum seekers. Their sabotage on both has set back real reform and decent policies.


John Menadue is the publisher of Pearls & Irritations. He has had a distinguished career both in the private sector and in the Public Service.

This entry was posted in Environment and climate, Politics, Refugees, Immigration and tagged , . Bookmark the permalink.

For questions regarding our comment system please click here.
(Please note that we are unable to post comments on your behalf.)

3 Responses to John Menadue. The price we are paying for the Greens.

  1. Dear me those terrible Greens – I am stunned at how much power this minority has had. I think the greens parliamentary representatives would be bemused at your account of the extent of their influence. A careful look at the history of policy debate at the time suggests that if we are going to get in to the blame game with hindsight there is going to be plenty of blame to spread fairly widely and the lack of the ALP actually standing for anything much is going to have to be on the agenda.

  2. Avatar Paul Foord says:

    An alternative narrative is that Rudd was not committed to mitigating global warming (he wasn’t prepared to fight), and Gillard was prepared to have the Malaysians do the dirty work. Not to mention that it is Labor that has moved rightward.

  3. Avatar Margaret Bell says:

    Another example of the lack of foresight in those who would govern us. Just as the “great economic managers” didn’t stop to think that they would not easily be able to undo the brake on the economy that their “debt and deficit disaster” bloviations caused. And good, old-fashioned vision has been missing in the ALP in recent years, too. It’s very difficult not to just disengage.

Comments are closed.