MUNGO MacCALLUM. Students’ strike for climate action – and good on them for it.

The conservatives have got themselves into a terrible lather about last week’s climate change protest.  

The kids, of course, are utterly wrong – misguided, subverted, brainwashed – but by whom? Well, obviously their teachers, the crypto communists devoted to tearing down western civilization, which is, by definition, the only sort worth saving. It is hardly a surprise that they have given permission for the so called strike – after all, they probably suggested it in the first place.

But what about the parents, those whom the conservatives always regard as the ultimate authority for their children? They too were overwhelmingly supportive. Have they all been brainwashed too? Because if they haven’t, it would imply that the strike, far from some kind of aberrant Marxist conspiracy, is actually part of a mainstream movement, and the conservatives are the ones out of step.

Of course we already knew this –many opinion polls have confirmed it. But climate change denial extends beyond the science – to be even half way consistent it has to embrace some kind of silent majority to be legitimate. And if, as was proved earlier in the same sex marriage debate, there is no silent majority, then they are shown to be no more than a perverse and disaffected rump.

But the terrible reality is obviously too much for them to bear, so they continue to pretend that they are the only genuine arbiters of both public policy and public culture – their objection is not that the kids are brainwashed, but that they have not been brainwashed by them. In the case of education, that means not only reading, writing, and arithmetic, but also fear God, honour the Queen, sing the national anthem and salute the flag.

The idea of obeying your parents needs to be qualified, however; obey your parents when we think they are right, but if not, obey us. And let’s go further than the old precept that children should be seen and not heard – they shouldn’t be seen too much either. That’s why we insist that if they absolutely must protest, they should do it in their own time, when no one will notice.

The formula was always nonsense, but at a time when the new generation is increasingly socially aware, it is obviously unfeasible. I have an honours degree, but my 16 year old granddaughter is far better informed in a number of areas than I ever have been or ever will be. She was part of the protest, and I applaud her for it unreservedly She studied the issue, weighed it up, discussed it with parents and teachers, not to mention her fellow pupils. She knew precisely what she was doing and why, and I am pretty sure that was the case with the vast majority of the many thousands that turned out, not just in Australia but around the world.

Climate denial and inaction may be an easy option for the older generation which will never have to face the consequences of their refusal to act; it is not so simple for those who will suffer for the neglect of their elected representatives. They have every right – even a duty – to express their concern, even if it does mean taking the occasional day away from classes.

And good on them for it.

print

This entry was posted in Environment and climate, Politics. Bookmark the permalink.

3 Responses to MUNGO MacCALLUM. Students’ strike for climate action – and good on them for it.

  1. John Millar says:

    The irony – students berated for not staying at school, where they would be further indoctrinated by those left wing activist teachers.

  2. Lorraine Osborn says:

    Nice work Mungo. We went to the Coffs Harbour strike on the mid north coast to show solidarity with the young people in our city. About 1000 came and it was great. On God Save The Queen; I remember being chipped by a bloke, a stranger, in the pictures when I was about 12 for not standing up for GSTQ which was always played at the start of everything from the opening of a door. Those were the days.

  3. john tons says:

    Nothing new here Mungo. I took part in the various anti-Vietnam protests of the sixties and seventies. Then too, the accusation was made that we were being manipulated by our teachers. Little wonder that Abbie Hoffman enjoined us not to trust anyone over thirty.

Comments are closed.