MUNGO MacCALLUM. Theresa May and Malcolm Turnbull – same problems and same prospects.

The conservatives of the Anglosphere still don’t get it: their elitist prescriptions for both the economy and the society that houses it are simply no longer acceptable. The mob are ready to reject what has been dubbed the political class and are scrabbling for solutions that can embrace more prosperity, and, even more crucially, more equality. There is no sign either May or Turnbull have either the skill or the desire to provide them.  

Malcolm Turnbull can hardly rejoice about the conservative debacle in Great Britain last week.

But he must be feeling a perverse satisfaction that he is not the only mug who called an early and unnecessary election, aiming to increase his party’s majority and to cement his own authority, and ended up crashing an burning, surviving by a whisker.

Theresa May, like Turnbull, must now be contemplating what might have been. If only she had gone straight to the people in the euphoria of Brexit, instead of letting time for the implications sink in and the hangover to develop. If only she had campaigned harder on bread and butter issues, instead of putting all her increasingly rotten eggs in the Brexit basket.

If only she had provided a convincing excuse for forcing a weary electorate back to the polls rather than a transparent grab to enhance her own power and prestige. If only she had not given Jeremy Corbyn a chance to remake himself as a credible Labour leader when he was down for the count. Perhaps most poignantly, if only she had just sat tight with her smallish but secure majority and got on with the job of negotiating Brexit.

All of this must have resonated with the Australian Prime Minister as he is still attempting to pick up the pieces of his almost catastrophic misjudgment of last year. But while he may empathise with the hapless May, he may also feel that she still has an unfair advantage: she is not hostage to the fortune of an unruly upper house, an elected senate stuffed with the deplorables Turnbull’s gamble was supposed to expel forever.

May will have occasional problems with her House of Lords, but the lords temporal and spiritual will never go feral in the way the Ocker plebeians do on a weekly basis. But both she and Turnbull will have to deal with unpredictable minor parties and a rebellious and disillusioned backbench and to date neither appears to have mastered the brief.

Neither May nor Turnbull is not quite a lame duck Prime Minister, but neither is an effective boss of the farmyard either – and there is very little either of them can do about it. For various reasons, another attempt to clear the air with a new election is out of the question. It is a safe bet both of them will hang on to what is left of power until the last possible moment, so the realities of government mean that both will have to make do with whatever they can cobble together.

The two will meet face to face to discuss their travails with each other in about a month; in the meantime Turnbull has rung May to offer her what he called his congratulations for her re-election. No doubt he meant well, but it is hard to imagine that May welcomed the reminder that it was essentially a case of one dud commiserating with another.

The conservatives of the Anglosphere still don’t get it: their elitist prescriptions for both the economy and the society that houses it are simply no longer acceptable. The mob are ready to reject what has been dubbed the political class and are scrabbling for solutions that can embrace more prosperity, and, even more crucially, more equality. There is no sign either May or Turnbull have either the skill or the desire to provide them.

print

Mungo MacCallum is a veteran political journalist and commentator. His books include Run Johnny Run, Poll Dancing, and Punch and Judy.

This entry was posted in Politics. Bookmark the permalink.

Please keep your comments short and sharp and avoid entering links. For questions regarding our comment system please click here.
(Please note that we are unable to post comments on your behalf.)