

After decades putting the brakes on global action, does Australia deserve to host UN Climate Talks with Pacific nations?
November 14, 2022
As theCOP27 climate talksgot underway in Egypt this week, climate and energy minister Chris BowenannouncedAustralia would bid to co-host the annual United Nations climate summit with Pacific island nations in 2026.
Playing host to the worlds climate negotiations could be a very big deal. It would be the largest diplomatic event Australia has ever held and would have major implications for both climate policy and our international relations.
A successful summit would signal Australias shift from fossil fuel heavyweight to renewables superpower and herald a new era of regional cooperation with the Pacific. However, these outcomes cannot be assumed, nor can support from Pacific nations.
Over the past 30 years Pacific island countries have playeda crucial rolein the global response to the climate crisis. Meanwhile, Australia hassought to avoidobligations to cut emissions and has acted as a handbrake on global action, even while expanding coal and gas exports. This legacy cannot be put to one side easily, nor should it be.
To successfully bid for and host the UN climate talks, the Albanese government willneed to showAustralia really has changed by bringing more to the table, and taking coal and gas off the menu.
What would it mean to host a COP?
Australia has never hosted the annual UN climate talks. Doing so would be a chance to revive Australias international reputation and reposition us to embrace the benefits of a global clean energy economy.
Sydney or Melbourne would most likely host, as between 20,000 and 40,000 delegates would beexpected to attend. Apart from the technical negotiations, the summit would be an industry trade fair a chance to showcase Australias growing clean energy export industry.
Prime Minister Anthony Albanesearguesthat Australia has a once-in-a-generation opportunity to become a renewable energy superpower. He is right.
Australia can play a supersized role in the global transition to net-zero by exporting the clean energy commodities and critical minerals other countries need to cut emissions.
According to leading economist Ross Garnaut, Australia could reduce reduce global emissionsby 8%- especially by exportingzero-carbon metalsto growing economies in Asia. This would be the equivalent of cutting all the emissions of Europe and the United Kingdom.
Australian diplomacy matters, too. We have history as a responsible middle power, galvanising action to protect the environment. In 1982 Australia supported a global moratorium on commercial whaling. In 1989 former Prime Minister Bob Hawke championed a treaty toban miningin Antarctica.
With similar ambition today, Australia could broker a new era of global climate action, especially if we work with Pacific island nations as a regional diplomatic bloc.
Australias relations with Pacific island countries are more important than ever. In the context of Chinas growing interest in the region, Australia iskeen toreaffirm its place as the security partner of choice for island governments.
But Australia will need to take serious action on climate change, as the Pacific has made it crystal clear for decades that climate change is the regionssingle greatest threat.
Pacific leadership and Australian recalcitrance
Pacific island countries have led the global response to climate change in the decades since a scientific consensus on the issue emerged in the 1980s.
In 1990 theyformed a diplomaticalliance with island nations in the Caribbean and the Indian Ocean to pursue shared interests in UN climate negotiations. This alliance has since swelled to39 countries.
Indeed, the first draft of the 1997 Kyoto Protocol which required wealthy nations to reduce emissions wasput forward by Nauruon behalf of thisAlliance of Small Island States.
Pacific diplomats were also crucial for securing the 2015 Paris Agreement, which now guides international collaboration to cut greenhouse gas emissions and shift toward clean energy.
They have succeeded in shaping global climate action, despite the divergent position of Australia.
In fact, Australia has used its position as the most powerful member of the Pacific Islands Forum to try to weaken regional declarations put forward by island nations at key milestones in the global climate negotiations.
In the run-up to the 1997 UN Kyoto climate summit, for example, Prime Minister John Howardrefused toback Pacific calls for a protocol with binding targets to cut emissions.
Similarly, ahead of the 2015 Paris climate summit, Prime Minister Tony Abbottrefused tosupport Pacific calls for a global treaty to limit warming to to 1.5 above pre-industrial levels. Pacific island states haveconsistently arguedthat this temperature threshold is key for low-lying nations such as Kiribati, Tuvalu and the Marshall Islands to survive.
In response,Kiribati President Anote Tong suggestedAustralia should leave the forum altogether if it wasnt prepared to back the islands positions in global climate negotiations.
When Prime Minister Scott Morrison again tried to water down a regional climate declaration at the Pacific Islands Forum in Tuvalu in 2019, a frustrated Fiji prime minister Frank Bainimaramatold waiting mediathat partnering with China was preferable to working with Morrison.
What Australia needs to bring to the table
To co-host the 2026 UN climate talks with Pacific nations, Australia will need to show its finally serious about tackling the climate crisis.
While Pacific leaders have welcomed Australias new 2030 target to cut emissions by 43% from 2005 levels they clearly expect more. Bainimarama haspointedly arguedfor Albanese to go further for our familys shared future by aligning Australias commitment to the 1.5-degree target.
By 2026, Australia will need to put in place policies that will drive deeper cuts to emissions, enabling us to strengthen our 2030 target and to set a much more ambitious 2035 target.
Global emissionsmust fall by 45% by 2030to have any chance of achieving the Paris Agreement goal of limiting warming to 1.5. A wealthy nation like Australia with vast, untapped, resources for renewable energy should be aiming to reduce emissions by 75% this decade.
At COP27 in Egypt yesterday,Tuvalu announcedit would join Vanuatus support for aFossil Fuel Non-Proliferation Treaty, intended to help manage a global transition away from coal, oil and gas.
Over the next four years, we can expect more Pacific nations to join this treaty, adding pressure to tackle Australias biggest contribution to the problem: coal and gas exports.
Australia should also end all fossil fuel subsidies, especially public support for fossil fuel projects.
Instead Australia will need to put more money on the table to help developing nations cope with climate impacts. As a start Australiashould increaseoverall commitment to international climate finance from A$2 billion to A$3 billion over the period 2020-2025.
As potential co-host for COP31, Pacific island nations will also expect Australia to contribute to a new global fund to address loss and damage from climate change. Expectations will only grow with New Zealandannouncing yesterdayit would provide finance for loss and damage, a movealready welcomedby island leaders.
This is the crucial decade
By 2026 the window for securing a safe climate will be closing fast.
Much can change in four years time. Over the past four years, we have seen more than 100 countries - representing90% ofthe global economy - commit to net-zero emissions. Most developed nations have committed to halving their emissions by 2030.
Despite these shifts, the world remains dangerously off-track. Even if all countries meet their current targets for emission reductions by 2030, the world is headed for2.4-2.6 of warmingthis century. This would be a cataclysmic outcome.
By hosting the UN climate talks, Australia could broker a new round of global ambition to cut emissions, and cement our place as part of the Pacific family. But first we will need to show were taking this crisis seriously.
Dr Wesley Morgan has written widely on climate change, and international relations in the Pacific islands. His research considers the ways countries work together at the UN to tackle climate change, and integrate climate change into their foreign policy and national security strategies. Wesley Morgan is a Senior Researcher with the Climate Council.
First published in THECONVERSATION Nov 9 2022
Wesley Morgan
Dr Wesley Morgan is a research associate at the Institute of Climate Risk and Response at UNSW.
He has written widely on climate change, and international relations in the Pacific islands. His research considers the ways countries work together at the UN to tackle climate change, and integrate climate change into their foreign policy and national security strategies.
Wesley also has over a decades experience living and working in the Pacific islands, where he worked as Pacific Policy Advisor with Oxfam, and taught postgraduate courses in diplomacy at the University of the South Pacific.
Wesleys research considers the impacts of climate change on Australia and Pacific island countries, and the international context for Australian climate policy.
Wesley is a fellow at the Climate Council and a research fellow at the Griffith Asia Institute (Griffith University).