Roger Scott. A Response to ‘Trust Me, I’m an Expert’

The podcast ‘Trust Me, I’m An Expert (10 September) is one of The Conversation’s rare forays into Queensland politics. It is a podcast from a much-valued series of gatherings held regularly at the Avid Reader bookshop in Brisbane’s West End.

The event brought together two of the shining lights among the analysts of Queensland political history – Ann Tiernan and John Cole. Both have a keen appreciation of the distinctive characteristics of Queensland’s political system while dismissing quasi-racist notions that Queenslanders are permanently and irreconcilably different from the rest of Australia – and probably more stupid.

Tiernan makes the point that Queensland has outgrown the red-neck image projected during the Bjelke-Petersen over thirty years ago and that half the current population have arrived since then. As a result, the dismissive pejorative ‘Mexican’ is rarely heard these days and Joh gets no credit for taking seriously the idea of a hydrogen car.

Drawing on a different academic tradition, Cole notes that the generic significance associated with the rural/urban cultural divide exists irrespective of state boundaries. It just happens that Queensland has a larger spread of ‘rural’ to the north and the west and a concentration of ‘urban’ in the south-east corner. He also provides a valuable history lesson about the experience of the regions in the fraught negotiations creating our current federal system. This has reinforced the continuing sense that northerners were dudded in never getting their own state.

But Tiernan and Cole both make the point that the ALP’s horror at the national election result in Queensland was exaggerated by the fact that there were so many marginal seats in play in Queensland which failed to change hands. Percentage swings were not so very different to those experienced elsewhere and they mattered equally in northern Tasmania and in Western Australia.

Tiernan and Cole also sought to identify one special characteristic among Queensland voters. Queenslanders take care about how to make their votes count. They will readily abandon presumed traditional loyalties if they are dissatisfied with current policies. This explains a willingness to punish the ALP Bligh government over public sector assets sales by giving Campbell Newman a massive majority and then immediately cancelling that when Newman applied private sector values in areas of employment and union regulation.

In the recent past, voters were willing to punish the ALP for its inconsistency about the tension between climate change and coal mining (‘different state, different story’) and its threat to middle-class incomes associated with investments in housing and superannuation. This did not mean they voted enthusiastically for the Liberal-National alternative but instead supported maverick options like Katter, Palmer and Hanson (even if preference distribution ended up hurting the ALP).

‘Dark money’ was clearly mobilised against the ALP. Palmer used his redirected millions to bluff the electorate into regarding him as a serious contender for office. In retrospect, it seems he was mainly concerned to avoid a federal government standing in the way of holders of coal leases alongside those of Adani.

And Greens and Get-Up were no help at all to the ALP, especially over Adani. Bob Brown’s crusade through rural Queensland irritated everyone across the state. And mobilising the personal loathing for Peter Dutton drained away resources from neighbouring constituencies where grassroots campaigns proved more effective in resisting the anti-ALP swing.

Since the national election, Queenslanders have continued to manifest this volatility as the focus has shifted back to state matters with the looming local election in a year’s time. The ALP’s internal ructions at state level and the national problem with the CFMEU have allowed a lack-lustre opposition to be able to bide its time and wait for its turn. A series of scandals or accusations of corrupt practice have been grabbing headlines about those close to the Premier’s office, about her house-purchasing deputy and about several local councils. NSW is trying hard, but the surreal case which led to the gaoling of the former Mayor of Ipswich takes some beating for unanticipated consequences. Polls – for whatever they are now worth – have suddenly started to respond to this accumulation of bad news for the ALP by pointing to a probability of regime change to a colourless alternative female party leader.

Tiernan and Cole offer a sensible and wide-ranging catalogue of policy areas where regional concerns loom large on the political horizon, especially access to advanced vocational education as well as university access and the potential for locating employment opportunities in non-traditional start-up industries. Cole instances the vision of the Wagner family and others in Toowoomba creating a private-sector airport expanding the range of export options.

Tiernan and Cole make harsh and accurate comments about regional perceptions of being bypassed by the political process, including the loss of local media, the narrow occupational base of the political class of both parties and the general disparity of opportunities and services between regional communities and urban locations.

Tiernan and Cole have been around for a longish time. I was pleased to note that Tiernan now has a title of Dean of Engagement at Griffith and Cole of PVC of Engagement at the University of Southern Queensland. Such university titles are frequently linked to a different set of organisational goals which do not place the Queensland community at the apex. It is gratifying to see that this is not the case at Griffith and USC.

Roger Scott has been a Professor of Public Administration, a Dean of Arts and a Director-General of Education in Queensland. He currently teaches at the University of the Third Age.


Roger Scott has lived in Queensland since 1977, apart from time out establishing the University of Canberra. In Brisbane, he has been a professor of public administration at the University of Queensland, a director-general of the state department of education and a dean of arts at QUT.

This entry was posted in Politics. Bookmark the permalink.

For questions regarding our comment system please click here to email P&I support.

2 Responses to Roger Scott. A Response to ‘Trust Me, I’m an Expert’

  1. roger scott roger scott says:

    I take John’s point about resistance of sugar farmers to uncomfortable truths, which I agree is self-interested. I am not wholly convinced that this is peculiar to Queensland but I agree about the idiocy of their elected representatives. However I am equally convinced about the idiocy of attention-seeking politicians from my native Tasmania who believe that it is possible to be agnostic regarding climate change, as if religious choice is involved.

  2. Avatar John Thomas says:

    I know that Roger is a great defender of the people of Queensland against the accusation that they are somehow different from other Australians. However, in disagreeing with him and also avoiding a high falutin’ academic argument with Tiernan and Cole, I would simply like to point out that right along the east coast of Queensland sugar farmers are resisting a legislative requirement to reduce the run-off of fertiliser and pesticides from their farms that marine scientists say are damaging the Great Barrier Reef. They had 10 years to take voluntary action but refused to do so. Now they are depending on the support of a rogue academic to continue their destruction of the reef.
    So we can list an anti-intellectual resistance to scientific knowledge, a self-interested reluctance to take any action to save a natural icon, and a general rural idiocy as elements of the fine folk of rural and regional Queensland.
    Mind you, the people of the North and Far North are fully supported by the LNP dimwits they elected on May 18. One of them has pinned the problems of the reef on ‘plastic straws’. Problem solved.
    And yes, I daresay, after all that I have said, that the good folk of Queensland are no worse than the all the other “quiet ‘strayans’ around this dying country.

Comments are closed.