Australia needs a capability state
Stewart Sweeney

Australia needs a capability state

Australia has immense natural, financial and scientific wealth, but has failed to turn enough of it into productive industries, skills and long-term national capability.

The disappearance of political shame
John Frew

The disappearance of political shame

The Labor party has drifted away from its principles when it comes to funding public education, one of the nation's defining democratic institutions.

AUKUS leaves Australia with the long nuclear goodbye – part two
Peter Briggs

AUKUS leaves Australia with the long nuclear goodbye – part two

In the second of a two-part series, Peter Briggs examines the decommissioning, dismantling and waste-disposal risks Australia will inherit from AUKUS reactors.


Multiculturalism is the middle ground Australia needs
Robin Brown, Nick Bogiatzis

Multiculturalism is the middle ground Australia needs

In the first of a two-part series, Robin Brown and Nick Bogiatzis argue that the moral values claimed as Western are common human values – and deeply present in the world's oldest continuing culture.

Artists need copyright plus in the age of AI
Kathy Bowrey

Artists need copyright plus in the age of AI

Copyright law has long served owners and technology companies more effectively than creators. AI licensing now makes the case for stronger protection for artists.

Strengthening Medicare shouldn’t ignore the Australians who rely on private health cover
Meg Schwarz

Strengthening Medicare shouldn’t ignore the Australians who rely on private health cover

Before cutting private health insurance rebates, the government should hear older Australians who rely on cover as a safeguard against delay, uncertainty and worsening health.

Climate, not China, is the Pacific’s real security threat
Jeremy Rose

Climate, not China, is the Pacific’s real security threat

Australia and New Zealand warn about China’s missile test while spending billions on military integration and lagging on the climate threat facing Pacific neighbours.


John Menadue

Support our independent media with your donation

Pearls and Irritations leads the way in raising and analysing vital issues often neglected in mainstream media. Your contribution supports our independence and quality commentary on matters importance to Australia and our region.

Donate

A new multi-nodal world is taking shape
Chas Freeman

A new multi-nodal world is taking shape

In remarks delivered to Chinese participants in the Cambridge Executive Leadership Program, Chas Freeman argues that 500 years of Euro-Atlantic dominance has come to an end.

Concentrated power crushing freedom of expression in Cambodia
Andrew Fraser

Concentrated power crushing freedom of expression in Cambodia

What an edition of a Siam Reap newspaper reveals about law and politics in Cambodia and constraints on freedom of speech.

Environment: Governments must use the evidence to encourage low-carbon lifestyles
Peter Sainsbury

Environment: Governments must use the evidence to encourage low-carbon lifestyles

Encouraging people to adopt low-carbon lifestyles is useful but no silver bullet for climate change. Plus, deep sea mining of thermal vents may look commercially attractive but will lead to the extinction of many unique animals.

Before the AUKUS submarines arrive, Australia inherits the risks – part one
Peter Briggs

AUKUS

Before the AUKUS submarines arrive, Australia inherits the risks – part one

In the first of a two-part series, Peter Briggs examines the technical and security risks of relying on highly enriched uranium and an unproven British reactor design for AUKUS submarines.

For Putin, anything short of victory is defeat
Nina L. Khrushcheva

For Putin, anything short of victory is defeat

Russia is feeling the cost of the war, but Putin’s authority rests on victory, force and fear. Lasting peace would require a political reckoning.

How the Royal Commission should define antisemitism
Gareth Evans

How the Royal Commission should define antisemitism

Drawn from his submission to the Royal Commission, Gareth Evans argues for a definition of antisemitism that protects Jewish Australians without suppressing legitimate criticism of Israel.

Who restrains power when power refuses restraint? – Message from the Editor
Martyn Pearce

Who restrains power when power refuses restraint? – Message from the Editor

Across this week’s pieces on P&I, the same question keeps appearing: who or what restrains power when the powerful decide restraint is optional?

New ‘G Minus 2’ order, Trump red-line test, and sea’s real battles – Asian Media Report
David Armstrong

New ‘G Minus 2’ order, Trump red-line test, and sea’s real battles – Asian Media Report

Nations’ new ways of working together, Xi’s nuclear deterrent display, scandal probe’s link to scandal probe, South China Sea’s geopolitical reality, Korean company’s record market listing, and the region’s shadow baby trade.

Gaza: from genocide to engineering genocide
Refaat Ibrahim

Gaza: from genocide to engineering genocide

In Gaza, Israel's systematic process of engineering genocide is stripping Palestinians of their aspirations and humanity. Their lives have been reduced to mere biological survival.

How big is the wolf? China in the Pacific
Jocelyn Chey

How big is the wolf? China in the Pacific

China’s Pacific missile test deserves scrutiny, but it should be understood in the context of decades of naval development and deterrence, not treated as proof of an imminent threat.

No case for muzzling ABC and SBS reporting on Israel
Greg Wilesmith

No case for muzzling ABC and SBS reporting on Israel

Claims of ABC bias against Israel in its reporting of current Middle East conflicts defy the truth and the professional and impartial tradition of ABC staff reporters.

From Astral Weeks to the “Iron Cage”: Van Morrison and the disenchantment of the World
Adrian Rosenfeldt

From Astral Weeks to the “Iron Cage”: Van Morrison and the disenchantment of the World

Van Morrison’s career traces a cultural movement from youthful openness and spiritual wonder towards bitterness, calculation and disenchantment.

The world does not need more risk managers
George Browning

The world does not need more risk managers

Politics and institutions are increasingly governed by risk management, not leadership. But real leadership requires imagination, courage and the willingness to challenge false stories.

The antisemitism commission must hear the voices it excludes
Jepke Goudsmit

The antisemitism commission must hear the voices it excludes

The focus of Block 3 of the Royal Commission into Antisemitism and Social Cohesion was on online hate but the commission did not hear about the hate directed at pro-Palestinian groups. 

Australia's disability budget – a plea for recalibration
Justin Glyn

Australia's disability budget – a plea for recalibration

Australian governments can find billions to spend on weaponry that maims but not on the NDIS, which is facing budget saving measures that will have malign consequences. 

The government asked charities what reform was needed; it has the answer
Mark Gaetani

The government asked charities what reform was needed; it has the answer

Reforms to strengthen protections for public interest advocacy by charities need to be legislated this year. 

John Menadue's book on Israel's war against Gaza

Israel's war against Gaza

Media coverage of the war in Gaza since October 2023 has spread a series of lies propagated by Israel and the United States. This publication presents information, analysis, clarification, views and perspectives largely unavailable in mainstream media in Australia and elsewhere.

Download the PDF

Latest letters to the editor

Jerusalem Declaration on Antisemitism

Mark Diesendorf — Sydney NSW

Gareth Evans offers a valuable, detailed analysis of the inadequacies of the IHRA working definition of antisemitism. But he does not mention an important alternative to the complicated process of patching up the IHRA definition and its so-called 'examples'. It was developed by a group of 270 scholars in the fields of Holocaust history, Jewish studies, and Middle East studies. The Jerusalem Declaration on Antisemitism is concise, less open to ambiguity and misuse, and likely to be more effective in combatting genuine antisemitism. It is simply: Antisemitism is discrimination, prejudice, hostility or violence against Jews as Jews (or Jewish institutions...
Mad Trump and nuclear weapons

David Griffiths — Mordialloc VIC 3195

While debatable, restraint is preferable to the irrational, bigotry and madness of Donald Trump. There is an issue that has not been discussed – the possible use of nuclear weapons by an angry, irrational and grotesque US President who regards himself as an immune and that his only restraint is himself. My fear, our fear, should be that Trump may opt for a nuclear option to resolve his Iran issue and that the failure to condemn the illegal war on Iran will encourage Trump to believe that his use of a nuclear bomb is justified and, if so, then, Australia...
No accountability, no restraint

Peter Sheehy — Blackheath NSW

Australia paid $2b to America to upgrade their boat building infrastructure, so they can provide us with second hand subs..........maybe..........if they feel like it. Australia has paid $2b to the UK for much the same thing. Australia paid $2.4b to France as progress payments for building subs under contract. Australia paid $1b to France to end the sub building contract. Outcome zero. That is a total of $7.4b and what do we have to show for this expenditure, nothing. Australia paid $41m for the Robodebt RC. Outcome was zero. Australia pays $16m for the NACC which investigated Robodebt (three times)....
The Israeli lobby accountable for antisemitism

Alistair Campbell — Bacchus Marsh, Victoria

Gareth cites Moore-Gilbert’s three categories of antisemites: Islamist Extremists, Neo-Nazis, and those whose abhorrence of the Israeli government have crossed a line into antisemitism applied to the diaspora. The first two categories will always exist, in small numbers. It’s the third category that really impacts social cohesion. And in my opinion that’s where the Israeli lobby needs to be held accountable. It seems that the lobby demands 100% compliance from Government and Institutions or they’re labelled antisemitic. The deliberate conflation of anti-Israeli, anti-Zionist and antisemitic is important here. Both the Federal Government and the ABC lean over backwards to accept...
We are discussing murder here

Hal Duell — Alice Springs

There is something self-indulgent to the point of obscenity in this nit-picking and comma-splicing attempt to define antisemitism, necessary though that may be. Every day we argue, and every day the hungry, homeless and hurt in Gaza are being hunted, targeted and killed. They are given no recourse to appeal their sentence, and their supporters and defenders are being hounded from the public space. Whether or not a random undergraduate at this or that Australian university feels a vague sense of unease is simply not the point. We are discussing murder here, and there really is no other way to...
Gareth Evans defines what offends others

Simon Tatz — Melbourne

Gareth Evans joins many other non-Jews is defining what is and isn't free speech and offensive. And like other non-Jews, he will never in his life experience or be subjected to antisemitism. Would Evans prescribe what is and isn't homophobic and/or racist? I doubt it. Some of my LBGTIQ+ friends say things to each other that would be an offence if others said them. It's their right to do this, as we see in America where black people have reclaimed the most racist and offensive or white vilification words. Evans and co don't get it; they have no right to...
The USA versus China: China wins every time

Les Macdonald — Balmain NSW 2041

In US war-gaming against China the US has lost in every conceivably realistic scenario. The outcomes varied depending upon the assumptions made but in the end the result was clear, and the fundamental reason, despite all the complicating factors is that the war would be fought on Chinese soil or in the surrounding waters, as there is no conceivable reason for China to invade the US. Similarly China would almost certainly lose to the US if the situation were reversed, even with their vastly greater industrial, technological and military power. The reason is simple in that in either case the...
Indecency masquerading as serious policy

Les Macdonald — Balmain NSW 2041

Rubio is just the last in a conga-line of US politicians who have adopted the US belief that they are the indispensable nation, with a God-given right to tell every one else how and by whom they should be ruled and that they must comply with US set requirements that do not apply to themselves. This is simply another repeat of the conceit of empire that has been a feature throughout organised human societies. But it is unquestionably the worst. As a recent study published in the Lancet demonstrated, from 1971 to 2021 US economic warfare against other countries was...