Pearlcast episode

Pearlcasts

As we review 2025, the temptation is to look for neat summaries and settled conclusions.

Go to Pearlcasts
Genocide is the story, not antisemitism
John Menadue

Genocide is the story, not antisemitism

The Australian government’s response to Gaza, and its handling of President Isaac Herzog’s visit, has blurred the line between antisemitism and criticism of Israel. The result is deeper division, weaker democracy and greater risk to Jewish communities.

Message from the Editor
Catriona Jackson

Message from the Editor

We've had a huge response this week to the news that John is stepping back from daily involvement in running Pearls and Irritations in order to write and enjoy life more.

Lai sentenced, Beijing doubles down on HK security – Asian Media Report
David Armstrong

Lai sentenced, Beijing doubles down on HK security – Asian Media Report

China’s ‘zero tolerance’ white paper to Takaichi’s all-powerful supermajority, opposite views on India-US trade deal, why BYD is beating Tesla, Cambodia war a key to Thai PM’s victory, and the K-pop path for Bad Bunny – news, opinion and analysis from across our region



How did the Liberals’ first female leader find herself on the mat in under a year?
Michelle Grattan

How did the Liberals’ first female leader find herself on the mat in under a year?

Sussan Ley’s rapid collapse as Liberal leader reflects her own limitations – but also a party struggling with factional dominance, ideological fracture and relentless polling panic.

Victoria’s school funding deal locks in inequality
John Frew

Victoria’s school funding deal locks in inequality

Victoria’s latest school funding agreement freezes public schools below the Schooling Resource Standard, formalising stagnation while preserving the language of reform. Delay is not neutral – it compounds disadvantage and entrenches inequality.

From pride to fear – how police violence changed how we see Australia
Toya Adams,  Laurie Shears

From pride to fear – how police violence changed how we see Australia

Toya Adams and Laurie Shears describe attending the Sydney protest against President Herzog’s visit – and how police violence left them fearful, shocked and questioning Australia’s democratic foundations.

Judge rebukes US defence secretary over bid to silence retired veteran
Brad Reed

Judge rebukes US defence secretary over bid to silence retired veteran

A federal judge has blocked an attempt by the US defence secretary to punish a retired naval officer and senator for speaking out, delivering a sharp rebuke to efforts to narrow constitutional protections for veterans.

Grace Tame, free speech and the return of political punishment
Greg Barns

Grace Tame, free speech and the return of political punishment

Calls to strip Grace Tame of her Australian of the Year award over her protest speech highlight a troubling slide towards political punishment and selective free speech.

An incomparable job, an honoured place as Founder
David Armstrong

An incomparable job, an honoured place as Founder

John Menadue, and the late Susie Menadue, did an incomparable job in conceiving, establishing, growing and nurturing Pearls and Irritations as a brave and independent alternative to the conformity of Australia’s legacy media.

Angus Taylor looks like a leader on paper – but the job is bigger than that
Michelle Grattan

Angus Taylor looks like a leader on paper – but the job is bigger than that

Angus Taylor has all the on-paper qualifications to be opposition leader. But what's needed now is a miracle worker to lift the struggling Liberal Party from its existential crisis.

Iran’s comprehensive peace proposal to the United States
Jeffrey D. Sachs,  Sybil Fares

Iran’s comprehensive peace proposal to the United States

A regional peace settlement grounded in Palestinian statehood, international law and mutual security guarantees offers a real alternative to perpetual conflict.



Latest on Palestine and Israel

Iran’s comprehensive peace proposal to the United States
Jeffrey D. Sachs,  Sybil Fares

Iran’s comprehensive peace proposal to the United States

A regional peace settlement grounded in Palestinian statehood, international law and mutual security guarantees offers a real alternative to perpetual conflict.

The Herzog visit and the Israelisation of antisemitism
Peter Hooton

The Herzog visit and the Israelisation of antisemitism

Inviting Israel’s president to Australia in the wake of the Bondi attack has blurred the line between antisemitism and legitimate criticism of Israel, weakening rather than strengthening social cohesion.

Cowardice dressed up as authority on Sydney’s streets
Stuart Rees

Cowardice dressed up as authority on Sydney’s streets

The violence surrounding protests against the visit of Israel’s president was not an accident of crowd control. It reflects a deeper political failure – where authority suppresses dissent rather than confronting uncomfortable truths about Gaza, protest rights and democratic responsibility.

When peaceful protest is allowed to work, democracy works
Catriona Jackson

When peaceful protest is allowed to work, democracy works

Melbourne’s mass protest against the visit of Israel President Isaac Herzog showed how large, diverse crowds can assemble peacefully when police exercise restraint and common sense. Sydney’s response points to a deeper failure of judgment about protest, power and democracy.

Salt, light and the visit of Isaac Herzog
Frank Brennan

Salt, light and the visit of Isaac Herzog

As controversy surrounds the visit of Israel’s president, Frank Brennan reflects on how Australians might respond with moral seriousness, legal clarity and a commitment to justice for all.

Herzog greeted by mass protest despite limits on marching
Alison Broinowski

Herzog greeted by mass protest despite limits on marching

Denied permission to march, thousands still gathered in central Sydney to protest the visit of Israel’s president. The demonstration revealed both the scale of public anger and the state’s increasingly fraught response to dissent.

Inviting a foreign president to Bondi’s commemoration divides rather than unites
Raghid Nahhas

Inviting a foreign president to Bondi’s commemoration divides rather than unites

Inviting a foreign head of state to commemorate an Australian tragedy blurs citizenship, religion and geopolitics – and risks undermining social cohesion at a moment that demands unity.

Antisemitism laws, double standards and Australia’s unfinished reckoning
George Browning

Antisemitism laws, double standards and Australia’s unfinished reckoning

Proposals to legislate new antisemitism definitions raise hard questions about identity, equality before the law, and why Australia continues to avoid confronting its most entrenched forms of racism.


John Menadue's book on Israel's war against Gaza

Israel's war against Gaza

Media coverage of the war in Gaza since October 2023 has spread a series of lies propagated by Israel and the United States. This publication presents information, analysis, clarification, views and perspectives largely unavailable in mainstream media in Australia and elsewhere.

Download the PDF

Latest on China

Confucianism, not coercion – China’s long export of a governance philosophy
John Hopkins

Confucianism, not coercion – China’s long export of a governance philosophy

Claims that China is exporting authoritarianism rest on a shallow reading of both Chinese political tradition and how governance ideas actually travel. A longer historical view points instead to Confucianism – a philosophy that has shaped governance across East Asia for centuries.

Australia unlikely to follow US downgrade on China threat
Marcus Reubenstein

Australia unlikely to follow US downgrade on China threat

The US National Defense Strategy signals a softer, more pragmatic approach to China. Australia’s silence on the shift exposes how detached its defence posture has become from both reality and its own national interests.

The China AI panic misses what history keeps teaching us
Fred Zhang

The China AI panic misses what history keeps teaching us

Warnings that China must be cut off from advanced AI chips echo a familiar pattern. History suggests technology bans rarely slow China down – and often do the opposite.


John Menadue

Support our independent media with your donation

Pearls and Irritations leads the way in raising and analysing vital issues often neglected in mainstream media. Your contribution supports our independence and quality commentary on matters importance to Australia and our region.

Donate

More from Pearls and Irritations


Latest letters to the editor

Don't mention the root causes

Hal Duell — Alice Springs

The deadly explosion from Gaza of Palestinians was the predictable blowing of a pressure cooker. For years the roughly two million Palestinians in Gaza had been living under a full air, land and sea blockade imposed by Israel. Israel also had its hand on the taps controlling water, fuel, medicine, food and movement. Occasionally they would dial a tap down a bit. They called it cutting the grass. To preface the litany of Israeli atrocities in Gaza with a reference to the events of October 7 as the monstrous Hamas-led attack is an attempt to seize and shade the narrative....
Increase taxes

John tons — adelaide

In 2026 we will be faced with both state and federal elections. Here in SA the theme among some of the parties is that they will cut taxation; a theme that will no doubt frame much of the narrative for most opposition parties. It is time that we called this out. The real debate should centre on who pays the taxes and what do we use those tax dollars for. The aim should be to shift the tax burden on those most able to pay - the top 10 per cent of society be they individuals or corporations...
AUKUS vs India: a strategy and cost critique

Ravin Nair — Canberra, ACT

John Queripel's critique of AUKUS offers a powerful fiscal warning, but his comparison to India’s Project 75(I) deal rests on a false equivalence. Comparing a $10 billion conventional fleet to a $368 billion nuclear one ignores the immutable geographic realities Australia faces. India’s German-designed diesel-electric boats are excellent littoral assets for regional two-front threats. However, they lack the endurance required for Australia’s vast maritime approaches. As ASPI notes, nuclear propulsion (SSN) provides the persistent, high-speed range that conventional boats – limited by battery and fuel – cannot match. For Australia, a conventional fleet would be exhausted before even...
Menadue understands power of lobbyists

Simon Tatz — Melbourne

John Menadue understands better than most the power of foreign lobbyists on Australian governments. From the alleged cover up by Prime Minister Whitlam of the Balibo 5, to Australian government's refusal to recognise the Armenian genocide, or the way they seemingly won't prevent a powerful trading ally from spying on activists in Australia, this country has long been captive to foreign pressures. Why Israel is seen as different to Indonesia, Turkey, China, India or US, or held to a different standard, isn't surprising in the current environment.



Latest from Al Jazeera

UK court says Palestine Action ban ‘unlawful’: What does the verdict mean?
Activists welcome the court ruling but the UK government says it will appeal the verdict.
What does BNP’s landslide mean for Bangladesh’s post-uprising order?
The victorious BNP was sceptical of constitutional reforms outlined in July Charter - now it must implement them.
Israeli settlers injure dozens of Palestinians in wave of West Bank attacks
Latest attacks come amid a widely condemned Israeli push to cement control over the occupied Palestinian territory.
US and Europe must ‘repair and revive transatlantic ties’: Germany’s Merz
German leader seeks to set tone of unity at Munich Security Council, as top US diplomat says 'new era in geopolitics'.
Logistics giant DP World replaces chief named in Epstein files
DP World appoints new chairman and group CEO following departure of Sultan Ahmed bin Sulayem over ties to sex offender.
Bangladesh’s BNP claims landslide win in first election since 2024 uprising
Party led by Tarique Rahman says it will form government by Sunday.