The man who did everything right
Kos Samaras

The man who did everything right

The story of a voter who did everything Australia once told working people to do: work hard, buy a home, raise a family and keep faith. Now, after years of lost jobs, debt and broken promises, his look towards One Nation is not loyalty but a warning.

Hannah Arendt and the creation of Israel
Robert Manne

Hannah Arendt and the creation of Israel

Hannah Arendt warned in 1948 that a Jewish state built without Jewish-Arab agreement would live by permanent war, fear and exclusion – a warning that now reads less like idealism than realism.

One umbrella, many stories: Why a "monocultural" Australia misses the point
Suzan Wahhab

One umbrella, many stories: Why a "monocultural" Australia misses the point

After Pauline Hanson’s National Press Club call for a “monocultural” Australia, Suzan Wahhab writes from her own family’s journey from occupied Palestine to Sydney to show that the fair go is strengthened, not weakened, by multicultural belonging.


Getting out of the Iranian quagmire
Shlomo Ben-Ami

Getting out of the Iranian quagmire

Trump wants to end the war with Iran. That involves protecting Lebanon from Israel.

The tragedy of AUKUS
Joseph Camilleri

AUKUS

The tragedy of AUKUS

In his submission to the AUKUS Public Inquiry, Joe Camilleri argues revoking AUKUS must be part of wider reassessment of Australia’s place in the world.

The questions Hanson was not made to answer
Alison Broinowski

The questions Hanson was not made to answer

Pauline Hanson’s National Press Club address gave the media a chance to test One Nation’s claims on racism, public broadcasting, nuclear power, AUKUS, defence spending and foreign policy – but too many of the hardest questions went unasked.

Inequality in Australia is growing
Allan Patience

Inequality in Australia is growing

To address inequality and the social problems it gives rise to, Australia must return to a robust mixed economy with essential services in public control.


John Menadue

Support our independent media with your donation

Pearls and Irritations leads the way in raising and analysing vital issues often neglected in mainstream media. Your contribution supports our independence and quality commentary on matters importance to Australia and our region.

Donate

China fear is weakening Australian research
James Laurenceson, Wanning Sun

China fear is weakening Australian research

Australia needs to manage research security risks, but exaggerating the threat of collaboration with China could weaken national security by cutting Australian science off from leading researchers, global expertise and crucial STEM talent.

Normally, I’m a friend of the taxman. But now ...
Ross Gittins

Normally, I’m a friend of the taxman. But now ...

The Tax Office has a duty to collect what is owed, but rising complaints show the system risks becoming heavy-handed, opaque and too hard to navigate for taxpayers trying to do the right thing.

Are the government's NDIS plans real reforms or just blunt cuts?
Sam Bennett

Are the government's NDIS plans real reforms or just blunt cuts?

The NDIS needs reform, but the government risks using blunt short-term cuts to meet Budget savings targets before the harder work of building fairer assessments and foundational supports is in place.

Don't destroy public education in the name of reform
Trevor Cobbold

Don't destroy public education in the name of reform

Save Our Schools rejects the idea that fully funding private schools would achieve equity. What is needed is proper support for public education.

Peace needs funding and commitment, not lip service
Sue Wareham

Peace needs funding and commitment, not lip service

Australia’s defence budget is set to nearly double over the next decade, while peace research, diplomacy and conflict prevention remain underfunded despite being essential to reducing the risk of war.

Who will release the next pandemic?
Julian Cribb

Who will release the next pandemic?

The next pandemic may emerge from wildlife trade, intensive farming, land clearing, laboratories, global travel or antibiotic resistance, as human behaviour continues to multiply the risks of another major disease outbreak.

Why Indonesia’s protests won’t shake Prabowo yet
Duncan Graham

Why Indonesia’s protests won’t shake Prabowo yet

Student protests against Prabowo Subianto’s militarised style of government have exposed anger over prices, corruption and civil liberties, but without broader public support or elite pressure they are unlikely to threaten his hold on power.

Gotcha, or getting tax right?
Crispin Hull

Gotcha, or getting tax right?

As the government’s hearing on its tax changes enters its second day, tax reform will be harder to defend if capital tax changes are left standing alone, and Labor should link them directly to bigger income tax cuts for wage and salary earners struggling with the cost of living.

The Albanese government and the lobbying scourge
John Menadue

The Albanese government and the lobbying scourge

Declining trust in government is helping fuel One Nation’s rise, and the failure to properly regulate lobbying has left powerful insiders in gambling, defence and fossil fuels with too much influence over public policy.

When the sky falls and the Chinese cars invade (again)
Fred Zhang

When the sky falls and the Chinese cars invade (again)

Australia’s media coverage of China too often collapses the distance between capability and intent, turning commercial activity and military assessments into a climate of threat that weakens rather than strengthens strategic judgment.

The Iran deal exposes the futility of Trump’s war
Amin Saikal

The Iran deal exposes the futility of Trump’s war

A fragile US-Iran agreement may end a war that failed to topple Tehran or destroy its nuclear capacity, leaving Iran with greater regional leverage, Israel exposed and Washington facing hard questions about what the conflict achieved.

AUKUS and democracy: why both matter
Leanne Minshull

AUKUS and democracy: why both matter

A Commissioner on the Public Inquiry into AUKUS responds to Waleed Aly's view that the inquiry will have no impact.

Stateless people need protection, not removal to Nauru
Katie Robertson

Stateless people need protection, not removal to Nauru

As the Senate Legal and Constitutional Affairs References Committee prepares to report tomorrow, Australia’s latest Nauru arrangement should be terminated because it deflects obligations to refugees and leaves stateless people facing prolonged legal limbo without durable protection.

Decolonising democracy – part eight
John Keane

Reclaiming Democracy

Decolonising democracy – part eight

In the final part of this series, John Keane asks whether democracies will have the resolve to stand up to the USA and to find remedies for the maladies of representative democracy.

The case against the AUKUS submarine project
Gareth Evans

The case against the AUKUS submarine project

In a submission to the public inquiry into AUKUS, former foreign minister Gareth Evans argues the submarine project is not in Australia’s national interest, warning that doubts over delivery, excessive cost and loss of sovereign agency demand an urgent Plan B.

Australia cannot fix housing without more density
Michael Keating

Australia cannot fix housing without more density

Housing costs account for much of Australia’s cost-of-living crisis, and affordability will not improve unless governments increase housing supply where people need to live, including through greater urban density.

John Menadue's book on Israel's war against Gaza

Israel's war against Gaza

Media coverage of the war in Gaza since October 2023 has spread a series of lies propagated by Israel and the United States. This publication presents information, analysis, clarification, views and perspectives largely unavailable in mainstream media in Australia and elsewhere.

Download the PDF

Latest letters to the editor

Message from the Editor

Jani Brodie — Melbourne

Re the Editor’s Message from June 13. ‘As we all mourn the terrible violence against immigrants in Belfast, and the continuing murder of innocents in so many places - including Lebanon and Palestine…’ I’m astounded that the ‘terrible violence’ by an immigrant inflicted on an Irish National fails to even warrant a cursory footnote here. Is the victim, and the wider consequences of the instigator’s actions, not even worthy of that?
Outsourcing responsibility

Bob Pearce — Adelaide SA

We are regularly reminded of the failure of privatisation /outsourcing all very nice when the outsourced services THRIVE on the built in redundancy in such services as the PMG. I believe that Telstra is still profiting from the removal of the old copper phone lines. The satellite system provided by private companies has helped the government budget bottom line, but like the electricity grid eventually when the services are not up to standard or need upgrading public pressure will force an injection of taxpayer funds.
The Empire's fall is accelerating

Les Macdonald — Balmain NSW 2041

The objective science which saw the rise of the US empire in so many diverse fields is now being scrapped in favour of voodoo science which fits the the imaginings of the current unhinged President. If you examine the fall of just about every empire in human history it is redolent with such actions in the vain hope that by doing so the collapse will be arrested and the empire re-born stronger than ever. History also tells you that not one such effort has ever been successful. Indeed, they have all accelerated empire collapse. There is no reason to suppose...
Set housing in context of population policy

Jenny Goldie — Cooma NSW

The authors rightly note that the energy performance of Australian housing is notoriously poor and that housing that is costly to heat or cool, or that makes its inhabitants sick, is not affordable housing. There doesn't seem to be any requirement anywhere, for instance that homes are sited properly on the block, namely, with some windows at least having north-facing orientation. The gap between overall supply and demand, however, appears to be the overarching problem. Increasing supply is generally seen as the solution as though demand cannot be managed. And yet it can. It's mostly a matter of population growth,...
Time to reconsider Hugh Stretton's critique

Bruce Wearne — Ballarat

Australia has failed to embed research and innovation into its national identity... Countries that invest in research and development are investing directly in their future prosperity... Science, research and innovation have become politically important. These were the same mantras intoned by “Dawkins Reforms” apologists, aimed at critics of the 12/1987 Green Paper, who were said to be defending the ivory tower establishment, preventing Australia's adjustment to the new world order. Ignored critics of the Dawkins reforms, like Hugh Stretton, considered the value of higher education to be under serious threat of a Government-induced commercialisation. Carr's article relies upon a latter-day...
The Shape of Things To Come (©HG Wells)

Leigh Bunting — Adelaide

AUKUS – created by stale thinking of the 1930s where yesterday's technology is 'proven' but will fail to pass the pub test in a generation. It's the same thinking that held up turbine technology from the beginning of WW2 to near its end. SSN's are cold war technology which will only benefit the coffers of military industrial complex with taxpayer money. We need to rid the 'system' of conservative thinkers and fill with future thinkers. I'm picturing the movie 'Of Things To Come' here. Less of 'The Boss' preaching from a pile of rubble and more like John Cabal's Wings...
People are very angry

K Southwell — Adelaide

Mr Waterford's article was, as usual, very perceptive. One Nation and other similar populist parties are also winning as people are angry and rightly or wrongly blame established parties. Try dealing with your telco, the banks, Australia Post – you'll sit for ages on some phone line to overseas or try and deal with a chat bot. And in Parliament party hacks in the main from both sides defend the indefensible. Expensively suited wordsmiths from sheltered lives mouth the usual platitudes. Look at the ALP now defending the use of A1 for aged care and NDIS and refusing to do...
AUKUS and the case for submarines

Shay O’Brien — Melbourne VIC

In this article the question is being asked if Australia really needs to have any submarines at all. Although I do share many of the doubts about AUKUS, as an island country surrounded by oceans, I would argue that we should maintain a strong submarine force to strengthen and enable our ability to exercise sea control of our EEZ and as a serious deterrent. Submarines are extremely useful weapons and are not at all obsolete nor going that way any time soon. Nearly every other country that has a need or desire and capacity to protect its maritime territory and...