The Productivity Commission has exposed the failure of WA’s GST windfall
Saul Eslake

The Productivity Commission has exposed the failure of WA’s GST windfall

The Productivity Commission has found that the 2018 GST reforms are failing on efficiency, effectiveness and fairness, while Western Australia continues to benefit from billions in funding. 

Catriona Jackson

P&I is growing. Help us keep up the fight – Message from the Editor

Another 250,000 readers found P&I over the past year. As our August fundraising campaign begins, we’re asking readers to help keep independent journalism free, fearless and growing.

Help keep
P&I independent

No corporate owner.
No paywall.
No advertising.
Powered by readers.

Become a regular supporter

PEARLS AND IRRITATIONS

John Menadue’s Public Policy Journal


Australia is running deficits – and leaving the bill to the kids
Ross Gittins

Australia is running deficits – and leaving the bill to the kids

Australia is running budget deficits. That means today’s taxpayers are not fully paying for the services they receive – and younger generations inherit the debt.

Shadow flights: Australia’s F-35 parts pipeline to Israel now runs through the US
Peter Cronau

Shadow flights: Australia’s F-35 parts pipeline to Israel now runs through the US

Leaked shipping records show Australian F-35 parts continuing to reach Israel on passenger aircraft, with shipments now routed through the United States rather than Thailand.

Democrats should make Trump’s $1.1 million an hour impossible to ignore
Ralph Nader

Democrats should make Trump’s $1.1 million an hour impossible to ignore

The reported $2.2 billion in profits involving Donald Trump and his family during his first year back in office has prompted scrutiny of the president’s financial interests. The Democrats should make the scale of the gains more tangible and push for greater scrutiny of presidential conflicts of interest.

Fighting inflation without making inequality worse
Mark Diesendorf

Fighting inflation without making inequality worse

Interest rates are a blunt tool for tackling inflation, and can hurt the people least able to absorb higher costs.


Help us reach $250,000 in new annual support

P&I is powered by you, our readers. No corporate owner. No paywall. No advertising.

AUD 0 of AUD 250,000 0% of our goal

Become a regular supporter

Campaign ends 30 September 2026.


Are we getting too good at managing homelessness?
Fabian Webber

Are we getting too good at managing homelessness?

Australia’s homelessness response has become increasingly sophisticated, but emergency accommodation and outreach cannot substitute for a home. The focus must shift towards prevention, permanent housing and addressing the systems that push people into homelessness in the first place.

China’s EV success was built on more than government intervention
Fengming Lu, Xiao Ma

China’s EV success was built on more than government intervention

China’s rise as the world’s leading electric vehicle producer offers an interesting case study in industrial policy. Its experience shows how competition between government agencies, local governments and private capital can drive experimentation and innovation, while also creating challenges for governments seeking to support emerging industries.

AUKUS Pillar One, part two: The nuclear dilemma – acquiring a sustainable, sovereign undersea capability
Jon Stanford, Michael Keating

AUKUS Pillar One, part two: The nuclear dilemma – acquiring a sustainable, sovereign undersea capability

In the second of a two-part series, the focus turns to nuclear stewardship. AUKUS would leave Australia responsible for weapons-grade uranium throughout the submarine lifecycle, while lower-enriched alternatives may offer a safer and more sovereign path.

Why the US-Iran ceasefire collapsed
Sarah Shamim

Why the US-Iran ceasefire collapsed

A US-Iran ceasefire agreement intended to pave the way for 60 days of peace talks collapsed amid renewed military strikes and disputes over the Strait of Hormuz. With both sides accusing each other of violating the deal, negotiations remain deadlocked and the wider war shows little sign of being resolved.

Labor’s 28 per cent should spell danger. Instead, it could be enough to win
Crispin Hull

Labor’s 28 per cent should spell danger. Instead, it could be enough to win

Labor’s primary vote has fallen to just 28 per cent as One Nation’s surge splits the right, yet the government remains on track to win the next election. With preference flows still uncertain, Labor faces pressure to address voters’ concerns over immigration, housing and the cost of living.

Productivism won’t fix Australia’s economic woes
Allan Patience

Productivism won’t fix Australia’s economic woes

Australia’s productivity debate is overlooking the deeper economic problems created by decades of neoliberal policy.

Australia’s home ownership rate doesn’t tell the whole story
Karl Fitzgerald

Australia’s home ownership rate doesn’t tell the whole story

Australia’s home ownership rate is 66 per cent when counted by household, but just 51 per cent when counted by person. The difference leaves millions of Australians living in an owned home without owning one themselves – and changes how we should understand Australia’s housing crisis.

The growth of Chinese soft power, and the decline of America's
Richard Cullen

The growth of Chinese soft power, and the decline of America's

Global opinion is shifting towards China as its technology, manufacturing and development record strengthen its appeal, while decades of war and political turmoil erode America’s standing.

Seven hours to prove he speaks English: Gaza students in visa limbo
Meg Schwarz

Seven hours to prove he speaks English: Gaza students in visa limbo

Young Palestinians offered a place by Irish universities shouldn’t lose that future because the mechanisms of a visa system can’t accommodate the reality of the place from from which they are applying.

AUKUS Pillar One, part one: The nuclear dilemma – strategic and operational concerns
Jon Stanford, Michael Keating

AUKUS

AUKUS Pillar One, part one: The nuclear dilemma – strategic and operational concerns

In the first of a two-part series, AUKUS is examined as a strategic choice, not simply a procurement program. The planned submarines are designed for US-led coalition warfare rather than a self-reliant defence of Australia.

The democratic danger of knowing more and understanding less
Stewart Sweeney

The democratic danger of knowing more and understanding less

Humanity has built an extraordinary system for producing and sharing knowledge, yet many people still lack a broad understanding of the systems shaping their lives. That gap is becoming a democratic dilemma.

Are the rich and old to be pitched against the young and poor?
Jack Waterford

Are the rich and old to be pitched against the young and poor?

Making housing affordable for younger Australians will require lower land prices and a major increase in housing supply. But the rush to build risks sacrificing planning standards, urban amenity and sustainability, while the labour shortage makes immigration an unavoidable part of the equation.

NDIS reforms are coming. Who could lose support?
Mona Nikidehaghani

NDIS reforms are coming. Who could lose support?

Proposed NDIS reforms would tighten eligibility, cut some participation funding and move hundreds of thousands out of the scheme, while replacement supports remain uncertain.

The planetary emergency is here. The warnings are getting louder
Julian Cribb

The planetary emergency is here. The warnings are getting louder

Decades of scientific warnings have done little to change humanity’s course. A new warning looks at the interconnected pressures facing the planet and what can be done about them.

Cuba needs energy security, not another generation of collective punishment
Vijay Prashad

Cuba needs energy security, not another generation of collective punishment

Six months of intensified US pressure on Cuba’s energy supply have deepened blackouts, transport failures and shortages. The immediate need is humanitarian relief; the longer-term answer is energy sovereignty.

AUKUS Infrastructure, part 7: Sorting the submarine source and sustainment stalemate
Peter Briggs

AUKUS

AUKUS Infrastructure, part 7: Sorting the submarine source and sustainment stalemate

In part seven of the AUKUS infrastructure series, the focus turns to Henderson, where fragmented planning risks locking Australia into costly nuclear bottlenecks before construction has properly begun.

John Menadue's book on Israel's war against Gaza

Israel's war against Gaza

Media coverage of the war in Gaza since October 2023 has spread a series of lies propagated by Israel and the United States. This publication presents information, analysis, clarification, views and perspectives largely unavailable in mainstream media in Australia and elsewhere.

Download the PDF

Latest letters to the editor

Visas for New Zealanders?

Jenny Goldie — Cooma NSW

Alan Gamlen and Peter McDonald provided some useful statistics and reminded us that New Zealanders require no visa to enter Australia. According to the table provided, it is part of the immigration program where there is no control. The number of New Zealanders moving to Australia was about 41,000 people in 2025, a 12-year high after averaging about 37,000 annually between 2005 and 2019. Australians, of course, can enter New Zealand without a visa under the Trans-Tasman Agreement. However, if we are to take control of our own immigration program, then we need to either cap the number of annual...
The elephant in the room

Jenny Goldie — Cooma NSW

Julian Cribb notes that the greatest elephant in the room is the fact that we have four times more humans than the planet can sustain. Unless overpopulation is also addressed, all other solutions must fail, says Cribb. We are indeed in overshoot and need to pull back, but how to get down to two billion from the current eight billion? Japan and now China are showing the way with negative population growth. Western Europe and South Korea are on a similar track. Africa's population, however, is still exploding and is expected to grow by another billion by mid-century. Fertility rates...
Volume of immigration is the issue

Graham Clews — 29 Apperly Close, Kambah, ACT. 2902

Why do writers such as Jack Waterford persist in characterising the discussion of immigration as immigration versus no immigration? This is NOT the discussion being had. It is about the volume of immigration. Even O.N. and Hanson, do not argue for an end to immigration but a reduction to 130 000 pa, about 50 per cent above the long-term average. And is immigration, over the longer term, really a must? To make this claim successfully, he & others need to explain why, despite some 8 million migrants since circa 2000, we still have a vast array of claimed skill shortages...
Who will care for those migrants leave behind?

Graham Clews — 29 Apperly Close, Kambah, ACT. 2902

Haque tells us that the impact of immigration on population growth is unimportant. He then presents a case in which population growth is central. Haque is not breaking new ground, as he suggests, in discussing the importance of immigration to our care economy. This subject is trotted out by the promoters of immigration at every opportunity. The real problem is that the subject is not being discussed honestly. One glance at our current demographic profile by age and migration status tells us that immigration is not solving our care challenges so much as ensuring far greater challenges in the future....
Five years on and no better

George Douvos — Victoria

Kos, your article brought tears to my eyes not because it was sad or emotional but because the trauma is still raw. To hear or read these comments that you made, evokes a sense of hope, a hope that millions will be heard and in a way justice will be done, but somehow I feel maybe not. I do know that the Labor government has to go, it’s too much pain and hurt that has afflicted on its citizens. Anyone other than them at this I would be happy with. Hopefully One Nation gets in and rattles them all. Thanks...
Propping up AUKUS

Ian Bowrey — HAMILTON SOUTH

I have read many times, the observation that the first country to unleash an atomic weapon will create a response that will end life on this planet. So I do not understand why certain men in politics with no training in the destructiveness of warfare can be allowed authority to embark on a program to equip Australia with nuclear weapon capable submarines. Questions about integrity, truthfulness, sovereignty, let alone cost are deflected by those with red and blue ties. Who really benefits from the AUKUS decision? In what form does that benefit exist? Many words have been printed and spoken...
Aged care and migrant workers

Meg Schwarz — Macclesfield, South Australia

I found the suggestion that Australia needs to “wean itself off migrant workers” in aged care concerning and, from my experience working in the sector for years, overly simplistic. There is certainly a need to train more Australians, improve wages and conditions, and make caring professions more attractive, but this doesn't mean migrant workers should be regarded as a temporary dependency that we should ultimately eliminate. Aged care has long relied on overseas-born workers because many Australians simply don't want to undertake this demanding, poorly valued work. We have always had jobs in Australia that are difficult to fill domestically...
Philosophical inquiry is the answer

John Turner — inverloch, Victoria

Stewart Sweeney’s article correctly pinpoints what is probably the most fundamental issue of our time. It seems to me that the answer lies in a radical change to our methods of education, in essence we need to look back to antiquity for our inspiration. Adopting a ‘Philosophical Inquiry’ approach to education develops critical thinking and a greater understanding of society. Also, giving more prominence to the arts rather than current fixation on educating for specific workplace skills, develops sensitivities and creative talent that will serve humanity well in a world that is becoming increasingly complex and out of balance.