One Nation is the symptom. Labor must treat the cause
Kim Carr

One Nation is the symptom. Labor must treat the cause

One Nation’s rise reflects deeper economic insecurity, political alienation and distrust in institutions. Defeating it requires more than condemnation.

Catriona Jackson

P&I is growing. Help us keep up the fight – Message from the Editor

Another 250,000 readers found P&I over the past year. As our August fundraising campaign begins, we’re asking readers to help keep independent journalism free, fearless and growing.

Help keep
P&I independent

No corporate owner.
No paywall.
No advertising.
Powered by readers.

Become a regular supporter

PEARLS AND IRRITATIONS

John Menadue’s Public Policy Journal


AI slop is learning to tell us what we want to hear
Jeremy Rose

AI slop is learning to tell us what we want to hear

AI-generated misinformation is not only exploiting anger and fear. Increasingly, it is feeding people comforting stories tailored to their politics and values.

Albanese governs with insiders and leaves voters outside the room
Jack Waterford

Albanese governs with insiders and leaves voters outside the room

The Albanese government may be adept at negotiating with insiders, but its failure to explain decisions and engage voters is deepening public distrust.

What Paul Keating wants for a country ‘swimming between sharks’
Wanning Sun

What Paul Keating wants for a country ‘swimming between sharks’

Paul Keating says Australia should resist strategic subordination to the United States without accepting Chinese dominance, and instead preserve its own sovereignty.

It’s too late for 1.5°C. That doesn’t mean we give up
Peter Sainsbury

It’s too late for 1.5°C. That doesn’t mean we give up

The UN now accepts that global warming is going to exceed 1.5°C but it’s unlikely that this will change anything governments or corporations do. It’s now too late to avoid catastrophic global warming. The task now is to limit further damage and prepare honestly for what follows.


Help us reach $250,000 in new annual support

P&I is powered by you, our readers. No corporate owner. No paywall. No advertising.

AUD 0 of AUD 250,000 0% of our goal

Become a regular supporter

Campaign ends 30 September 2026.


Aggression against school staff is a workplace failure, not a wellbeing problem
John Frew

Aggression against school staff is a workplace failure, not a wellbeing problem

Aggression towards teachers and principals is being normalised as something to manage, rather than treated as a workplace hazard employers must prevent.

Protesters challenge Israeli military-linked presence at Sydney Marathon
Mohamed Ainullah

Protesters challenge Israeli military-linked presence at Sydney Marathon

Hundreds of protesters lined the Sydney Marathon route over the presence of Israeli military-linked participants, calling for scrutiny under Australia’s character laws.

What antisemitism and homophobia have in common
Dennis Altman

What antisemitism and homophobia have in common

Antisemitism and homophobia have different histories, but both can cast minorities as threatening, subversive or powerful – and both belong in a broader response to prejudice.

Free in two senses – keeping P&I independent
David Armstrong

Free in two senses – keeping P&I independent

Pearls and Irritations depends on its readers to remain free and independent. David Armstrong explains why their support is vital as P&I reaches a growing audience seeking progressive perspectives.

The danger of not knowing what you don’t know, part two: Why Trump’s Board of Peace is floundering
Connie Peck

The danger of not knowing what you don’t know, part two: Why Trump’s Board of Peace is floundering

In the second of a two-part series, Connie Peck explains why Trump’s Board of Peace is struggling to turn its Gaza plan into reality as implementation stalls and critical institutions remain undeployed.

The far right feeds on grievance. Democracy has to answer it
Mario Peucker

The far right feeds on grievance. Democracy has to answer it

Falling trust, social isolation and a sense of lost status can make far-right politics more appealing. Rebuilding connection and democratic voice is part of the answer.

Powerhouse Parramatta is about to open without the leader who defined it
Samuel Cairnduff

Powerhouse Parramatta is about to open without the leader who defined it

Lisa Havilah’s departure just weeks before Powerhouse Parramatta opens leaves a museum shaped closely around her vision facing questions of leadership, authority and legitimacy.

Europe should stand with Canada against Trump’s economic coercion
Philippe Legrain

Europe should stand with Canada against Trump’s economic coercion

Trump’s escalating pressure on Canada should be a warning to Europe: middle powers need deeper economic and strategic cooperation if they are to resist coercion.

Australians are hunkering down – and becoming less happy
James O'Donnell

Australians are hunkering down – and becoming less happy

Australians are becoming less connected, trusting and satisfied with life, but resilience remains – and tackling insecurity could help rebuild social cohesion.

Nepal’s catastrophe demands more than climate silence
George Browning

Nepal’s catastrophe demands more than climate silence

As climate-fuelled disasters intensify, political leaders should stop treating discussion of their causes as untimely and confront the consequences of continued inaction.

What are we missing about Helen of Troy?
Adrian Rosenfeldt

What are we missing about Helen of Troy?

Debate over who can play Helen of Troy misses something more interesting: in Homer, she emerges as a rare figure capable of questioning fate, power and her own responsibility.

Britain’s security establishment has discovered the ecological crisis
Julian Cribb

Britain’s security establishment has discovered the ecological crisis

A UK national security assessment warns that ecosystem collapse threatens food, water, health and geopolitical stability – and that no country will escape the consequences.

Performance Politics: how Australian politicians write themselves into history
Dennis Altman

Performance Politics: how Australian politicians write themselves into history

Joshua Black's 'Performance Politics' traces how Australian politicians have used memoirs, publishing and television to shape public personas and secure their political legacies.

Reflections of a migrant's daughter
Glenda Korporaal

Reflections of a migrant's daughter

The death of Dutch migrant Dick Van Teulingen at 101 closes a chapter in Australia’s post-war migration story, shaped by those who left war-torn Europe to build new lives here.

Australia cannot deny its share of the climate catastrophe
Bob Brown

Australia cannot deny its share of the climate catastrophe

Bob Brown says Australia cannot keep expanding fossil fuel production while denying its share of responsibility for the mounting human toll of climate change.

The Shanghai Cooperation Organisation is becoming harder to ignore
John Queripel

The Shanghai Cooperation Organisation is becoming harder to ignore

The Shanghai Cooperation Organisation (SCO) now represents 3.4 billion people and a quarter of global GDP, as its members seek a greater role in shaping a multipolar international order.

John Menadue's book on Israel's war against Gaza

Israel's war against Gaza

Media coverage of the war in Gaza since October 2023 has spread a series of lies propagated by Israel and the United States. This publication presents information, analysis, clarification, views and perspectives largely unavailable in mainstream media in Australia and elsewhere.

Download the PDF

Latest letters to the editor

Federal Labor needs vision and narrative

David Griffiths — Mordialoc, Victoria 3195

Increased support for One Nation includes the failure of Federal Labor to articulate a believable vision and narrative – instead of timidity and caution. Federal Labor is supposed to believe in human rights, justice and democracy – except for Indigenous people, refugees and Palestinians and these exceptions expose hypocrisy. In the UK the right-wing Reform party has stalled because momentarily at least the new Labor prime minister is offering a vision and a narrative. It is doubtful that a changed Albanese, if this were possible, would be believable. The new UK PM understands that warnings about the threat of Reform...
The Albanese government is risk-averse

Ken Russell — Redcliffe, Qld

Mark Beeson's excellent article discusses the unlikely possibility of the Albanese government acting independently of Washington. Unfortunately, there is no chance the government will stop supporting coal and gas exports. It is not prepared to take the political risk of bringing on a fight with the powerful fossil fuel lobby. This is a major lack of leadership because the burning of fossil fuels is the main cause of climate change being an existential threat to life on Earth.
Medical and dental costs could be a game-changer

Meg Schwarz — Macclesfield, South Australia

Crispin Hull is right to identify medical costs and the prospect of bringing dental care into Medicare as an important electoral opportunity for Labor. The cost-of-living crisis isn’t confined to people receiving concessions. Increasingly, people on modest and even average salaries are putting off seeing a doctor because of the out-of-pocket cost. Bulk billing has increasingly become something people on concession cards can rely on, while working Australians can face significant fees simply for seeing a GP. Dental care is an even greater problem because for many Australians, the choices are limited to an already stretched public dental system or...
Migration is neither bad nor good but size matters

Jenny Goldie — Cooma NSW

My thanks to Alan Gamlen for a balanced article on migration. I welcomed his acknowledgement that: Emigration can deprive poorer countries of skilled doctors, nurses, engineers and other professionals. Rural areas may lose population. Families can spend years separated. These downsides are often forgotten by high-migration advocates, as indeed are the up-sides by the likes of One Nation. Gamlen says good migration is all about management. Yes, but that has to include size. Migration has to be set within population policy, so we do not exceed the carrying capacity of this continent. There is a great deal of evidence to...
TAFE barriers

neil hauxwell — Moe Vic

Indeed, we urgently need more Voc Ed students to have a sporting chance in an increasingly competitive industrial world, but attracting more students (and employers) will require a major reset of TAFE arrangements . The current TAFE system is dominated by Competency Based Training (CBT), a managerially approved recipe for training hub-cap fitters for the vehicle assembly lines of 1960. CBT has a philosophy that only properly trained folks with the word 'MANAGER' on their office door plaques are capable of complex human thought. It’s a dead philosophy for long dead industry practices. CBT has been rescued from oblivion by...
Transparency in the Catholic church

Kieran Tapsell — Stanwell Park

The lack of transparency in the Catholic Church reflects the famous line of the Sicilian aristocrat in Giuseppe de Lampedusa’s novel, The Leopard: “If you want things to stay as they are, things will have to change.” In 2019 Pope Francis abolished the pontifical secret over child sexual abuse but retained what he called “office confidentiality” for canonical proceedings. In 2020, in response to the Australian Royal Commission recommendation to publish the judgments in the Church’s disciplinary proceedings, the Holy See said that it would do so on a case by case basis, but that it had an obligation to...
Carbon offsetting has become greenwashing

Ken Russell — Redcliffe, Qld

Ross Gittins article identifies flaws with carbon offsetting. Sadly, a process that started with the good intention of accelerating global decarbonisation has become a greenwashing mechanism for the fossil fuel industry and complicit governments. A good test of the merits of carbon credits relates to who has paid for them and what this is allowing them to do. Fossil fuel companies are major users of carbon credits. This tells us all we need to know. You can't accelerate decarbonisation by burning fossil fuels!
Unaccountable and untrustworthy

Les Macdonald — Balmain NSW 2041

John's article raises the question addressed by the statement of Thomas Paine. “A body of men holding themselves accountable to nobody ought not to be trusted by anybody.” The Catholic Church in vast stretches of its existence has been answerable only to itself. That is 2000 years of self regulation. Any human institution, and the Church is unquestionably a human institution, that has no accountability to anyone but itself must, on the basis of overwhelming historical evidence, develop a vast capacity for impunity of action and distaste for any authority but itself. That has been the fate of any long...